2023 Phase I & Phase II Preliminary Drafts Informal Comment Period

29 Results

Sort:

Comment From: City of Olympia (Jeremy Graham)

3/23/23 @ 9:41 PM
Thank you for the opportunity to provide informal comments to the preliminary draft permit language.

We appreciate the work that was completed by Ecology and the PAC to help improve on the SSC program.

We also appreciate the opportunity provided to pha...↓

We ask that further consideration and time be given in order to develop a more robust public engagement and outreach process that includes overburdened communities. It could prove beneficial in allowing more time to prepare and work with our communities prior to pushing out and constructing projects solely focused on meeting the permit requirement of an acreage standard.

One final suggestion. Is it possible to consider including a multiplier or weighted factor in determining the acreage required for retrofits. While the current method of using population-to-acreage ratio seems fair, there are cases where it may not account for variations in industrial operations and building densities. For instance, some permittees with smaller populations may have more extensive industrial activities, leading to greater hard surfaces and pollutant loads. Conversely, some permittees with larger populations may have more compact urban areas with high-rise buildings. It may not be equitable to penalize the latter for implementing 'smart growth' standards. Would it be possible to explore ways to address these issues?

These comments are meant to help guide Ecology in further decisions when drafting the next round of formal permit language.
No attachments

Comment From: City of Renton (Kristina Lowthian)

3/23/23 @ 5:50 PM
The City of Renton appreciates the opportunity to comment on the preliminary draft of the Western Washington Phase II Permit for Stormwater Controls for Priority Developed Areas.

It may be challenging for jurisdictions to convince their councils and e...↓
No attachments

Comment From: The Nature Conservancy (Joshua Rubenstein)

3/23/23 @ 5:14 PM
Attachments:

Comment From: City of Renton (Kristina Lowthian)

3/23/23 @ 3:53 PM
The City of Renton appreciates the opportunity to comment on the preliminary draft of the Western Washington Phase II Municipal Stormwater Permit for Stormwater Controls for Priority Developed Areas.
Attachments:

Comment From: City of Marysville (Brooke Ensor)

3/23/23 @ 2:49 PM
Issue
"Projects that have started construction on or after June 30, 2023 and projects not yet started but fully funded by June 30, 2029 can be included to meet this requirement."

Justification
The date range does not acknowledge cities that have been pr...↓

The date range provided discourages larger projects from being pursued. The Downtown retrofit site had historical industrial use that left the site polluted. The City began the process of remediation nearly 15 years ago. Then conducted a project feasibility and alternatives analysis to determine the scope of the stormwater facility. Finally, design and construction work could begin. In order to secure funding for the full build out scenario, two Department of Ecology Grants were required. This project required significant planning efforts spanning multiple departments.

The level of effort may need to be adjusted (down) over time. Cities must consider a multitude of factors when attempting to achieve large capital projects. Economic factors, staff capacity, uncertainty of State grant funding and overall willingness of Councils to expend funds. Marysville has a successful retrofit program because grant funding was available and City Elected officials have approved these endeavors for the sake of water quality. The project timing was also important as the financial capacity was present to support such endeavors. Furthermore as we have seen over the last two years, delays have resulted in significant construction cost inflation. If the City had waited to initiate these projects, it very well could have taken another 15 years to be completed. During a downturn, or during times of strong inflation, approval for new projects might not be readily achieved. Other unforeseen utility funding calamities could also occur in aging utility infrastructure that require significant utility upgrades. In the future, the City may not be able to fund large projects like we have in the past.

Proposed Solution
Facilities do not provide stormwater benefit until constructed. Allow projects that started design or construction in the current permit term to be counted toward this requirement. If construction started between 2019-2024 stormwater benefit begins in the new permit term. Below are our preferred options ranked.
1) Include all retrofit projects completed during the current permit cycle.
2) Include all retrofit projects completed in the last two years of the current permit cycle.
3) Include all retrofit projects that are completed on or after Jan 1st 2023.
No attachments

Comment From: Stewardship Partners (Aaron Clark)

3/23/23 @ 2:44 PM
Dear Ms. Stockwell and Ms. Waterman,

Thank you for the opportunity to provide comment on the Phase I and II NPDES draft permits. Stewardship Partners is a Seattle-based 501(c)(3) organization. We create people-based solutions that engage Puget Sound c...↓

I appreciate the updated structural stormwater controls (SSC) sections of both the phase I and II permits in terms of the clear intention to increase environmental justice, address priority toxics like 6PPD-quinone, and increase the pace of retrofitting our existing pollution-generating impervious surfaces. My comments are simply that on those three key points, this permit cycle should require more progress on all three.

On environmental justice, I believe this permit should provide an explicit definition of environmental justice using the language already created by the state Environmental Justice Taskforce in their 2020 final report. Specifically, the permit should re-state and strive to follow the five EJ principles therein: "1. Achieve the highest attainable environmental quality and health outcomes for all people. 2. Adopt a racial justice lens. 3. Engage community meaningfully. 4. Be transparent. 5. Be accountable." And municipal permittees should be required to describe how their SSC/retrofit investments follow these principles.

On priority toxics and specifically 6PPD-quinone, I believe this permit should prioritize bioretention-based green infrastructure retrofits that are proven to reverse toxicity of highway runoff for aquatic life, especially Coho salmon. The highest priority (most points) should be retrofitting high pollutant load surfaces (e.g. high traffic roads) with bioretention-based green infrastructure.

On the pace of retrofits, I believe the current draft of this permit will not accelerate retrofits enough to meet the challenge. Stormwater is the single largest source of water pollution in our region. With dozens of proven effective retrofit strategies, the Clean Water Act, tribal treaty-protected rights as well as the rights of future generations all clearly demand more investment, not a gradual phasing in. Puget Sound is suffering death by a thousand cuts (thousands of outfalls) and it's hard to justify only applying one Band-Aid a year when it's feasible to do much more.

Thank you for considering these comments and for the important work you do to protect these waters and the communities that belong to them.

Sincerely,

Aaron D. Clark Ph.D.
Director of Strategic Partnerships
Attachments:

Comment From: Thurston County (Larry Schaffner)

3/23/23 @ 2:37 PM
Attachments:

Comment From: City of Seattle (Jessica Huybregts)

3/23/23 @ 12:57 PM
Attachments:

Comment From: City of Puyallup (Paul Marrinan)

3/23/23 @ 12:54 PM
-Clarify if jurisdictions can get credit for run-on to proposed new development treatment devices. Many times, these areas could be bypassed and if we can incentivize picking up additional area it could be very cost effective and beneficial to water...↓
-Please clarify if a construction project has begun prior to June 30th and continues after June 30th date, would this count. We do not believe the language is clear.
-Include incentives or bonus multipliers for utilizing SMAP proposed projects/ideas or implementing projects within the SMAP basins.
-Propose incentives or bonus multipliers for collaborations between municipalities.
-Can jurisdictions get credit for implementation of reimbursement programs on private property? Specifically, installation of rain barrels, rain gardens and permeable pavement projects reimbursed through a 'rain garden' program? These are private property retrofits that are beneficial to the MS4 by reducing peak flows and enhancing water quality.
-Can jurisdictions receive credit for a programs that allocate funds to implement habit restoration of private property along water ways within their jurisdiction?
-Do jurisdictions get credit for implementing an Urban tree sale program?
-Do jurisdictions get credit for being a tree City USA City?
-Do jurisdictions get credit for catch basin marking programs?
-Under 'Non-Qualifying Project types', there is an incomplete statement: Mitigation projects otherwise required to compensate for problems caused by excessive
-Do jurisdictions get credit under this program for habitat restoration and fecal field screening (for example) that we do to meet various TMDL requirements?
No attachments

Comment From: Local government- City of Both... (Janet Geer)

3/23/23 @ 12:16 PM
For the SSC program, we appreciate this requirement is allowed outside of the SMAP area.
The current calculations needed to establish points has been very problematic for Phase I jurisdictions, so we ask that Ecology find a better way to quantify the ...↓
For retrofitting existing systems, we appreciate the discussion regarding the inability to bring an existing system up to current standards. We have several ponds, for example, that would greatly benefit from additional flow control and/or water quality treatment that will not be able to be brought up to current design due to site constraints.
No attachments

Comment From: City of Kirkland (Rachel Konrady)

3/23/23 @ 12:08 PM
Please see attached document for comments
Attachments:

Comment From: Washington Conservation Action (Katie Byrnes)

3/23/23 @ 10:41 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: Pierce County (Maureen Meehan)

3/23/23 @ 8:42 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: City of Everett (Dana Zlateff)

3/23/23 @ 7:57 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: King County (Blair Scott)

3/22/23 @ 10:26 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: City of Tacoma (Merita Trohimovich)

3/22/23 @ 8:54 AM
Please see the attached file "City of Tacoma S5.C.7_Preliminary language comments".
Attachments:

Comment From: Snohomish County (Bill Leif)

3/22/23 @ 8:02 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: Rod Swanson

3/21/23 @ 11:00 PM
Attachments:

Comment From: City of Maple Valley (Halley Kimball)

3/20/23 @ 2:43 PM
See attachment
Attachments:

Comment From: City of Shoreline (Zachary Richardson)

3/19/23 @ 11:00 PM
Attachments:

Comment From: City of Redmond (Anne Dettelbach)

3/17/23 @ 9:11 AM
City of Redmond offers the following comments on the 2023 Phase II Preliminary Draft language (due March 23, 2023). We look forward to full draft permit language.

1. Redmond supports the use of an Equivalent Area Calculation approach to "prorate" flo...↓

2. Please clarify the statement that indicates permittees may include projects that have "not yet started but [are] fully funded by June 30, 2029." Does "fully funded" mean that construction has been fully funded?

3. All 12 SSC qualifying project types should be eligible for inclusion in non-SMAP (i.e., opportunistic) watersheds. Our SMAP watershed is not the only high priority watershed in the City and we would not want permit compliance to frustrate/override taking these actions in other watersheds.

4. Please explain how collaborative projects/15% work. Does this indicate that only 15% of our individual obligation can be met via a regional collaboration or that regional collaborations at the ILA/committed funding stage can be used to establish an EAC = 15% of acreage?

5. How is EAC for collaborative projects calculated? Is it based on percentage of land owned by each jurisdiction located in the watershed? How does this work if not all jurisdictions sign onto an ILA? Can a jurisdiction participating in a regional collaboration count a regional project/facility if the contributing sub-basin is outside the jurisdiction's limits (e.g., jurisdiction is located downstream of the retrofitted facility)?

6. Please clarify the statement: "Projects may be implemented outside of permit coverage area so long as the receiving waters within permit coverage area will benefit." Does "permit coverage area" refer to the overall Phase I/II permit coverage area, or the participating permittee's individual coverage area? The former interpretation makes good sense, the latter interpretation may discourage upper watershed permittees from participating.

7. Expanding the following statement to include the parenthetical will help address Tribal Waters/interests. "Projects may be implemented outside of permit coverage area so long as the receiving waters within permit coverage area [or on Tribal lands] will benefit."

8. Please consider allowing a permittee to "bank" flow control/LID/treatment retrofits undertaken in the 2024-2029 permit cycle and "claim" those improvements in the following permit cycle. If not entirely, perhaps this option can be offered for a portion of the total acreage required in future cycles. Allowing this will help build municipal/leadership support for larger regional facilities that, ultimately, bring about water quality improvements faster and at a larger scale than smaller retrofit projects.
No attachments

Comment From: Anonymous Anonymous

3/08/23 @ 8:37 AM
Ecology should allow permittees to accrue "level of effort" points for requiring private development to implement water quality treatment above what is currently required by the permit (i.e. requiring treatment in the first place for PGIS or requirin...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Anonymous Anonymous

3/08/23 @ 8:36 AM
Instream projects (fish barrier removal, in-stream habitat, etc.) should qualify for fulfillment of this permit requirement. This is because they can provide significantly more improvement for aquatic species than upstream pollution control alone. ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Anonymous Anonymous

3/08/23 @ 8:36 AM
Ecology needs to ensure that level of effort points awarded for "non-structural BMPs" is sufficient to give municipalities (especially small municipalities) better opportunity to comply with these proposed permit requirements. Doing so will also prov...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Anonymous Anonymous

3/08/23 @ 8:35 AM
Provide examples of how a small community can contribute to meeting an overall regional goal? As it is more cost efficiency to removing pollutants with regional or larger stormwater facilities, Ecology should consider allowing for permittees to pay ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Agency

3/08/23 @ 8:35 AM
There should not be a 50% cap on MS4 pipe cleaning, additional sweeping, and other enhanced maintenance activities toward fulfilling level of effort requirements. Studies have shown (see City of Tacoma study) that this type of enhanced maintenance is...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Anonymous Anonymous

3/08/23 @ 8:34 AM
If a permittee goes above the required level of effort in a permit cycle, that additional level of effort above what the permit requires should be able to accumulate "Bank" and apply toward level of effort in future permit cycles. If banking is not ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Bonnie Blessing

2/27/23 @ 2:54 PM
!) In countys with spotted frogs could you develop ways to help consultants 'determine whether a project will drain a spotted frog wetland'
2) Can you develop ways to decrease habitat suitability of stormwater ponds and stormwater pipes for bullfrogs ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Subhash Poudyal

2/23/23 @ 11:46 AM
1. I would like to suggest that threshold to qualify for HPGA definition be lowered to preferably 15,000 AADT and in any case no more than 20,000 AADT.
2. The projects addressing water quality problems in known problem areas seem to be unfairly treate...↓
No attachments