Regarding the current proposal to spray pesticides on oyster beds:
I am opposed to the idea based on what I have read reported in the Seattle Times on the topic. The possibilities for contamination and/or destruction of other life forms in the foo...↓d chain, are too great, the consequences of those possibilities too damaging, from what I can understand, and what I have seen happen over my lifetime.
Bernice Harris ↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Chris Schulz
9/22/17 @ 12:16 PM
Absolutely not. As I will never eat a farmed fish...I will never eat another oyster again if this chemical is used.
No attachments
Comment From:
Sarah McGraw
9/22/17 @ 12:01 PM
I love Washington shellfish, I value the industry, and I am alarmed to know the environment has changed enough to threaten the harvest. But I fail to see how introducing insecticide into that same changing environment can possibly do anything but has...↓ten its decline. I strongly oppose this proposal, and I urge you to reject it. ↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Catherine Newland
9/22/17 @ 11:11 AM
I am strongly against this proposal as the beaches and waters surrounding this could be affected. These pesticides have already been shown to have detrimental effects on honeybees so who knows what the effects could be on fish, crabs, clams and whale...↓s in the surrounding areas. We already have negative effects from elevated mercury levels from all the old mills in Washington State. The public should be able to be able to fish and enjoy the beaches as well without worrying about this becoming a health hazard. This is a step backwards and i hope it will not be allowed.↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Lisa Costantino
9/22/17 @ 11:10 AM
From the EPA: "When bees encounter imidacloprid at levels above 25 parts per billion—a common level for neonics in farm fields—they suffer harm. "These effects include decreases in pollinators."
Harming necessary species to help another species is...↓ foolish and irresponsible. This is a proven harmful pesticide. In no way should its use be allowed in our waters - or anywhere.
It's unfortunate that oyster growers are suffering economic losses, but environmental endangerment is not a valid tradeoff.↓
No attachments
Comment From:
herb nelson
9/22/17 @ 10:44 AM
There is no need to poison native species only to line the pockets of a few farmers. This poison migrates to the ocean and kills other valuable species. there is too much poison in the ocean already. Its rediculous to reconsider something that was al...↓ready curtailed. ↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Robert Nerenberg
9/22/17 @ 10:36 AM
I'm not interested in eating shellfish exposed to a chemical that DOE thinks about in this way: "There are still knowledge gaps about imidacloprid. Further research is needed." I don't want to be a test subject and will immediately stop eating Wash...↓ington oysters if this is allowed.↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Caitlin Morrison
9/22/17 @ 10:02 AM
I am an environmental epidemiologist. We do not want to spray these beds with imidacolprid. There is not enough data yet on the long term effects of use. There is not enough specificity yet in how they would spray (for example: only limit spraying to...↓ one section for the first ten years). We cannot afford to run experiments in our natural environment. We can not afford to put something in our water annually where we are not extremely confident in the outcomes, especially with neurotoxins. ↓
No attachments
Comment From:
James Nunn
9/22/17 @ 9:33 AM
Oyster growers and other harvesters of the sea, as is true of their land-based farmer counterparts, do not own the land, the shore, the water, no matter what documents they may provide which contend otherwise. They are temporary tenants and (hopefull...↓y) consientious stewards of these resources, belonging simultaneously to everyone and to no one.
We understand the desire of these stewards to prosper, but we cannot allow a shortsighted pursuit of individual prosperity to jeopardize the long-term viability of a resource which is the rightful and sacred inheritance of everyone--including those yet unborn. This is especially true of water, as it knows no bounds. Poison placed here is poison placed everywhere.
In short, this proposal is unconscionable, and therefore, absolutely unacceptable. ↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Julia Wayne
9/22/17 @ 9:15 AM
Do not let this happen.
No attachments
Comment From:
Margaret Donaldson
9/22/17 @ 8:42 AM
I am strongly against the use of Imidacloprid and all other neonicotinoid pesticides in Washington State waters. As a lifelong resident of Washington State, the health of our local environment is incredibly precious to me. Imidacloprid has three majo...↓r strikes against it: not only is it toxic to all invertebrate life where it is directly applied, it can be expected to spread to adjoining areas, disrupting not just invertebrate life there but all the rest of the food chain. There is also significant uncertainty about the cumulative impacts to other marine life. I have eaten Washington State oysters all of my life. While I value the oyster grower industry in this State, these growers must find a different way of managing the problem of burrowing shrimp. The cost to us all is far too high. ↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Susan Kernes
9/22/17 @ 8:21 AM
I reside in Seattle and frequently harvest clams, oysters and mussels in season. I strenuously object to ANY planned use of the pesticide imidacloprid to control burrowing shrimp on commercial shellfish beds in Willapa Bay and Grays Harbor. I rely on...↓ our pristine waters and shoreline not only for my personal use, but for the crustaceans and other nearshore clams, oysters and mussels that live along the shore and shallow waters. Simply put, any application of pesticides, no matter how benign the claims, is completely unacceptable. Thank you for considering my objection.↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Melissa Aaron
9/22/17 @ 8:15 AM
We don't know enough about the effects of this pesticide on the denizens of the tidal flats (crustaceans, fish, birds, and so on). It's toxic to mammals, so endangers orcas, seals, otters, and us. It's also toxic to bees. How can we possibly think th...↓at oysters are worth that? I love them as much as the next gal, but there's a point when the harm outweighs the good. We are at that point. Please do not approve the use of this pesticide.↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Michaela Barrett
9/22/17 @ 6:21 AM
Imidacloprid is a poison known to have toxic effects on not only insect pests, but also beneficial insects (bees!), birds, and marine invertebrates. It is unconscionable to deliberately apply this poison to an uncontained aquatic environment solely f...↓or economic gain.↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Penny Rand
9/22/17 @ 6:04 AM
Please do not destroy the environment with toxic sprays. Fish farms and oyster farms have created this problem and will destroy the wild fish and oysters not to mention humanity.
No attachments
Comment From:
Matthew Hart
9/21/17 @ 7:49 AM
I will try and keep this civil, but I must say it is difficult. You are talking about spraying pesticides directly into a bay of the Pacific Ocean, to appease a single oyster company? Are you kidding me? There are known, direct impacts, on a variety ...↓of invertebrates that are food for the salmon we depend on in the Pacific Northwest...this is based on your own supplemental environmental review. This has to be the most absurd idea I've ever heard. Please exercise some common sense and tell these jerks from the WGHOGA to go to hell. ↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Bob Triggs
9/20/17 @ 6:26 AM
Under NO CIRCUMSTANCES should we allow the application of insecticides on our waters and aquatic wetlands. Especially not this chemical, not on the mudflats. All adjacent invertebrate and vertebrate species will be affected. This will have implicatio...↓ns for juvenile salmon, steelhead, cutthroat trout, birds and other fish species. NO! NO! NO! ↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Jewell Hamilton
9/20/17 @ 2:30 AM
neonicotinoid pesticides should be banned. what about the bees?! even though this chemical application permit is for tidal areas, it will impact bees. I've seen all sorts of bees on the beach during my five and a half years as a professional beach c...↓omber (I sold sea glass). Please do not allow application or use of neonicotinoid pesticides for any use. Remember Rachel Carson. ↓