Western Port Angeles Harbor Sediment Cleanup Unit--Remedial Investigation/Feasibility Study & Amendment to the Agreed Order
Comment From:
Port Angeles Hardwood LLC (Mendenhall Marc)
3/16/20 @ 4:00 PM
No attachments
Comment From:
Port Townsend AirWatchers (Gretchen Brewer)
3/16/20 @ 12:44 PM
It is welcome to finally have cleanup action in sight. However, in agreement with comments submitted by Dr. Peter deFur and others, the proposal offers cleanup alternatives come from standard operating practices of the past and have been shown to be ...↓less effective than methods that have been developed and developing over these most recent two decades and are ripe for use here.
In the last couple of decades much research and many trials have allowed for better methods that actually remediate the contaminated areas. Much work has been done, e.g., with fungi (even underwater varieties), and other bio-forms that don't merely accumulate but actually convert the contaminants. I highly encourage the agency to review literature and consult with those who have been developing these methods, including your area's own Batelle Institute and Dr. Paul Stamets at the region's Fungi Perfecti, for instance.
This site would be an ideal proving ground for methods that these and other researchers have been developing and testing, and I submit that whatever of those methods tried, it would likely be much cheaper and more effective.
Of the proposals that are offered:
• Excavation and removal merely moves the problem from one place to another, replicating the contamination in another ecosystem. As they say, in the environment there is no "away" in which to throw things.
• Cover and contain: the contamination is still there. An impermeable cap means that that layer has effectively been killed. It ignores that mobility between soil strata is part of natural soil health.
• Cover and "jump start the natural recovery process" with sand or gravel layers. This one is baffling. Given the litany of chemicals that have accumulated in the Western Port Angeles Harbor sediments, this is a centuries-long process, so "jump start" is a conceptual stretch.
• Check on natural deposition: by itself, equals "do nothing" which is unacceptable as it merely leaves the contaminated mess. Checking on the process regularly should be part of any cleanup process.
A method or methods that actually convert the toxins in situ without killing or removing the natural living living harbor, have ripened for present use and would be much more cost effective and beneficial to the health of the site as a whole. I submit a request that those methods be used instead.
Thank you for your consideration,
Gretchen Brewer
↓
Comment From:
Port Angeles Business Associat... (James McEntire)
3/15/20 @ 2:17 PM
The Port Angeles Business Association is happy to provide the following comments on the Port Angeles Western Harbor Cleanup Remedial Investigation/Feasibility Study:
1. The preferred alternative looks to have struck a reasonable balance between c...↓leanup outcomes and input costs. To our knowledge, it will involve proven cleanup methods in use around the world. We support the preferred alternative.
2. Get it done! Port Angeles does not need a repeat of the failing effort to remediate the former Rayonier Mill site in the eastern Port Angeles harbor and upland area. That effort is still seemingly stuck – an unacceptable cleanup plan, coming decades after the mill closure, with no end yet in clear view.
3. We note that the contaminated sediments are the result of decades of legal industrial and manufacturing activities. The harmful effects of industrial and manufacturing byproducts were either unknown or not very well appreciated while those activities were ongoing. From a public policy perspective, it is more than appropriate that State and Federal budgets should contribute in a substantial way to the sediment cleanup. It will not help economically for the local public and private fisc to bear the entire cost of the cleanup effort.
4. The Potentially Liable Parties (PLPs) will have to bear considerable cost, even if insured against this kind of risk – either in increased insurance premiums, or in an inability to be insured against this type of risk in the future. As above, we need help from State and Federal budgets to help lessen local fiscal impacts and opportunity costs for the money spent from local coffers.
5. It is very appropriate for local governments and business entities to expect the same kind of outside financial support, in the same proportion to the overall effort, as other similarly situated communities have. This is not the first such effort undertaken in our state, and it is reasonable for us to think that earlier cleanup efforts in Western Washington have had substantial Federal and State financial support. If the Department of Ecology were to directly contract for some appropriate portion of the cleanup effort – since the contamination resulted from legal activities back in the day – there would be no constitutional issue of such monies going directly to private entity PLPs involved in this cleanup effort.
↓
No attachments
Comment From:
The Remediators Inc (Howard Sprouse)
3/15/20 @ 6:39 AM
Department of Ecology
Connie Groven
Cleanup Project Manager
Southwest Regional Office
P,O. Box 47775
Olympia, WA98504-7775
Re: Port Angeles Harbor Cleanup Site Cleanup ID 11907
The preferred cleanup remedies of intertidal excavation, intertida...↓l capping and the final selection of cleanup actions under consideration are intended to provide for the long term safety of the public and restoration of the environment in the most comprehensive and cost effective way. The modern bioremediation technologies we employ have been reviewed and approved by the EPA and the California Department of Toxic Substance Control. We have many successful projects in Superfund Sites, large industrial cleanup sites and private cleanup sites in 8 states within the lower 48 states and Alaska with several more beginning this year. The Integrated Biological Approach to bioremediation used by us and project partners at NASA/Ames Research Center relies on a combination of plants, microbes, and fungi for remediation of mixed contaminants of soil and groundwater. The technology combines patented plant/microbe pairings originating from and licensed through the University of Washington Forest Science Laboratory with fungi from our library of thoroughly tested fungal strains for remediation use. This process can deconstruct organic toxins completely as well as remove inorganic toxins and metals and concentrate them within the plant tissue effectively and at less cost than most other remediation technology. A trial using specially prepared biochar made for use within a thin-layer sand cap trial conducted from the Ashland Chemical Superfund Site on Lake Michigan outperformed 'Sedimite' and Granulated Activated Carbon (GAC), both for prevention of migration of toxins as well as providing a restorative function to the cap. These technologies are flexible, efficient, and restore the sites they are used on to a healthy condition. By combining these technologies as appropriate we are able to treat hard to treat as well as mixed contamination simultaneously with visible improvements to the site, often with minimal disturbance to the ground through our specialized application methods.Information on specific contaminants, site specific treatments, and supporting validation literature will be provided on request as well as presenting a sysnopsis of our previous and ongoing work.The addition of these technologies within existing treatment options provided for in the Port Angeles Harbor Cleanup will ensure that when completed the contamination is not simply covered up, rather the site is clean and restored to a healthy safe condition. ↓
Comment From:
Olympic Environmental Council (Darlene Schanfald)
3/13/20 @ 3:00 AM
No attachments
Comment From:
munro llc (grant munro)
3/12/20 @ 3:55 AM
Comments for Facility Site ID:18898
Site Cleanup ID: 11907
Connie Groven
Cleanup Project Manager
SW Regional Office
Dept. of Ecology
Dear Sirs:
I am wishing to comment on the Western Port Angeles Harbor Cleanup project. I have been acti...↓vely involved in this community for over 30 years with time spent on the City of Port Angeles Council as well as a board member on many significant organizations in this community. Thus I believe that I speak as a well informed member of this community.
It is critical that this project move ahead in the current preferred cleanup alternative and schedule. We have watched as so much time has been wasted with the Rayonier cleanup project where an important site is tied up and not contributing to the local economy. The preferred alternative gets this project done expeditiously , in a reasonable cost to the companies involved, and without further harm to the environment.
I support moving ahead quickly with the currently suggested preferred alternative.
Sincerely,
Grant Munro
↓
No attachments
Comment From:
James Mantooth
3/11/20 @ 1:50 PM
Please give serious consideration to the comments from Olympic Environmental Council based on analysis by its technical consultant Dr. Peter deFur, which OEC has submitted to you. The harbor is important to the well-being of our economy and ecology. ...↓Friends of Ennis Creek wants to be confident the fish that spend time in the harbor and their food sources in that area will not be contaminated.↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Roberta Mantooth
3/11/20 @ 1:35 PM
Please give serious consideration to the comments from Olympic Environmental Council based on analysis by its technical consultant Dr. Peter deFur, which OEC has submitted to you. The harbor is important to the well-being of our economy and ecology. ...↓Friends of Ennis Creek wants to be confident the fish that spend time in the harbor and their food sources in that area will not be contaminated.↓
Comment – Western Port Angeles Harbor Sediment Cleanup Unit – Remedial Investigation/Feasibility Study (RI/FS) and Amendment to the Agreed Order
Comments by Jim Haguewood, resident of Port Angeles
I support the RI/FS that has evaluated a range ...↓of cleanup alternatives for the subareas and provides the greatest degree of benefits, including protection of human health and the environment, within in a reasonable timeline and cost.
The preferred cleanup plan is a result of over a decade of study. A group of five public and private entities have worked cooperatively with the Department of Ecology to agree to a science-based plan that is cost-effective, using a proven implementation approach and meets the requirements of the Model Toxics Control Act, RCW Chapter 70.105D.
In the best interests of the citizens of the State of Washington and most importantly the residents and visitors of Port Angeles, please move this clean-up plan forward and get the job done.
↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Clallam County Board of Commis... (Clallam County Board of Commissioners)
3/04/20 @ 2:04 AM
See attached letter for comments from the Clallam County Board of Commissioners.
Loni Gores - Clerk
agores@co.clallam.wa.us
360-417-2256
On behalf of Karl Spees, M.D. (whose computer did not allow him to submit on this form), the following comment is submitted:
I am a scientist, a pragmatist, and a student of Natural history.
I will accept the premise that the historical PA In...↓dustries were producing some very toxic wastes at one time which they deposited in the harbor.
In today's Peninsula Daily News we have some public official who has come up with a reasonably expensive (multi-million dollar) solution to assuage the guilt trip the DOE has laid on the current inhabitants of Port Angeles. (Minimal improvement of the real problem but at a very large expense to the current general public.)
Here is the reality. Mother Nature has a phenomenal ability to heal herself. The best solution to a defiled-environment is to quit doing the destructive activity. Time heals all (mostly). The defiling of PA harbor has ceased many decades ago. Most of the problem has eroded away, been diluted, or has been embedded in a layer of silt. Ten thousand years from now the PA pollution of the 50's, 60's and 70's will be a thin line in a sedimentary mud or rock which is part of a mountain or ridge. (OK the layer could still be in some ocean location.) (Mother Nature herself has deposited some toxic materials in rock formations.) The bottom line is that if we 'do nothing', the crabs and shrimp of PA harbor will be nontoxic and edible. The Salmon traditionally bypass the harbor going to sea and returning. Doing it for the Salmon (or the children) is just emotional gibberish, blackmail. (The real reasons for our salmon resource's precipitous decline is a politically-incorrect cause which is unmentionable in bureaucratic circles.)
The Pragmatic Solution to our polluted PA Harbor is to 'do nothing'. "Stop the damaging behavior and "DO NOTHING!" Nothing will be lost and the problem which has already virtually disappeared will continue to be less of an issue.
Of course this policy will not satisfy the DOE, which makes this proposal unacceptable. (The DOE is about politics and control not acting on behalf of the WA State Citizens and the Environment.)
Karl Spees, M.D., Student of Natural History
↓
No attachments
Comment From:
Anonymous
Anonymous
1/22/20 @ 3:09 AM
This is an undue burden on taxpayers...to what end? The damage was done decades ago and time is the best solution at this point. Taxpayers are extremely weary and annoyed that unelected officials continue to drain our pocketbooks without voters hav...↓ing a say at the ballot box.↓
No attachments
Comment From:
George Titterness
1/20/20 @ 4:00 PM
No attachments
Comment From:
Stephen McKenzie
1/14/20 @ 12:09 AM
No attachments
Thank you for subscribing to the Western Port Angeles Harbor Sediment Cleanup Unit--Remedial Investigation/Feasibility Study & Amendment to the Agreed Order mailing list.