Cooke Aquaculture Pacific NPDES permits modifications to raise steelhead

152 Results

Sort:

Comment From: Ken Wood

9/15/20 @ 7:25 AM
Cooke Aquaculture has long since proven it's utter disregard for the law and it's utter incapacity to follow regulations. There is NO WAY to raise ANY fish in a pen without concentrating pollutants and spreading parasites to wild fish. NO. JUST. NO. ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Shannon O'Sullivan

9/14/20 @ 1:47 AM
Are you kidding me, When are you people going to put the people and fish of this state before money. Keep the poison out of Puget sound.
No attachments

Comment From: Keith Drynan

9/14/20 @ 1:28 AM
The modifications to these permits show a progressive approach by DOE to working with a professional aquaculture company and implementing workable guidelines to ensure a high standard of operations and protection of the environment in which they ope...↓
After the collapse of the pens and subsequent escape of significant numbers of non native salmon in 2017 the most vocal opposition to the operation was based on the species being raised.
The move to a sterile version of a native species should be accepted as environmentally sensitive and progressive move to local high quality food production via sustainable aquaculture, providing local employment and support of other local businesses.
No attachments

Comment From: lance magnuson

9/14/20 @ 1:02 AM
Dear Ladies and Gentlemen,

I'm am unclear why we are being asked once again for comments on Cooke's change to steelhead. The evidence is clear from past performance that Cooke is incapable of successfully maintaining a farm salmonid site.

The failure o...↓

Changing to another salmonid (steelhead) does nothing to indicate a change in corporate culture. While the fish may be all female triploids, based upon pen density, the risk of disease is greater. If and when the fish escape (and they will escape), there is risk of these fish intermingling with native stocks and spreading disease. This is an unacceptable risk.

Cooke hides behind the Jamestown S'Klallam Tribe, using their First Nation's status as a smokescreen of corporate responsibility. Cooke is intentionally using the natives to gain sympathy for this cause. Do not fall for this ruse.

I am unable to forgive Cooke for their unmitigated disaster at Cypress Island. Cooke is a hugely profitable Canadian company, with a long history in Canada. If they want this business with steelhead to succeed, move it to Canada. The Canadians seem to be more tolerant of corporate irresponsibility.

Sincerely,

Lance Magnuson
No attachments

Comment From: Patrick Townsend

9/13/20 @ 9:50 AM
It is shocking that Cooke would be considered for yet another net pen operation in Puget Sound following the ecological disaster they created previously. It is also shocking that WDFW and ECY would be considering another net pen operation in Puget So...↓

"Saying that Denmark's coastal and inland waters have become "overloaded" with nitrogen, the country's current environment minister Lea Wermelin, recently announced that licensed fish farms will be only for land-based operations."

Reference: https://www.rastechmagazine.com/ireland-fisheries-chief-sees-trend-towards-onshore-fish-farms/

Even traditional Northern European net pen operators are now moving to onshore operations to avoid the environmental impacts:

https://salmonbusiness.com/these-are-the-leading-land-based-salmon-farms-in-the-world-right-now/

The future for net pen and shellfish aquaculture is clearly with onshore, land-based operations. Just one facility currently in development in Florida will meet more than half the demand for salmon in the US. Washington State is in danger of becoming the dumping ground for unsustainable aquaculture operations with negative effects on our native fish populations and on our Southern Resident Killer Whale populations.

Just say No to all net pen operations in Puget Sound.

No attachments

Comment From: Danny Beatty

9/13/20 @ 2:48 AM
Once again, I am writing in opposition of any specie change for the Puget Sound Net Pens. In fact, I am in favor of eliminating now. Past operation by Cooke Aquiculture caused a reduction (Example - Cypress Island) in the number of net pens. It also ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Phil Gere

9/13/20 @ 2:02 AM
Please, no net pens in Puget Sound.
No attachments

Comment From: SARAH HANSON

9/13/20 @ 1:25 AM
I am opposed to all permits for Cooke Aquaculture in Puget Sound.
No attachments

Comment From: Elizabeth Sawyer

9/12/20 @ 2:21 PM
It is unacceptable that after seeing the amount of disease and parasites affecting our wild fish that come from allowing open-net fish farms - regardless of the species - that this department would even consider opening another one. It flies in the f...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Greg Abel

9/12/20 @ 8:34 AM
I have no problem with what is proposed providing it applies to all others raising fish in net pens including the
state. If that is not the case I would deem your conditions unreasonable and unfair. What applies to one must apply to all.
No attachments

Comment From: Paul Buehrens

9/12/20 @ 5:04 AM
The benefits here accrue largely to Cooke, and the risks accrue to the environment, and may be largely externalized to the taxpayers. There are better ways. We should be focussed on improving the environment for ALL species, not adding another risk...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Richarx Ereth

9/12/20 @ 2:38 AM
I absolutely do not support ANY permit to culture Steelhead Trout in ANY LOCATION in the marine waters of the Salish Sea. PERIOD.
No attachments

Comment From: Erik Kingfisher

9/11/20 @ 11:02 PM
I was pleased to finally see a moratorium on net pen aquaculture in Puget Sound after the 2017 incident, and I disagree with the effort to continue with net pen aquaculture, even with native species. The water quality and disease threat to the ecosy...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Laura G Medbury

9/11/20 @ 11:55 AM
I do not believe it is in the best interest of our waters or resident orcas regardless of pen raised finfish species. Discharges from pens such as fish feces, uneaten fish food, disease control chemicals milled into fish feed, biofouling organisms d...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Jeff Redburn

9/11/20 @ 10:52 AM
NO NO NO....We don't need another accidental release for the fish to go up the green and everywhere else. Generate money some other way.
No attachments

Comment From: Keith Shimizu

9/11/20 @ 7:48 AM
It's stunning that Ecology is even considering permitting an operation with the history of Cooke! Ecology and Cooke are another environmental accident waiting to happen while it allows disease and parasites to impact native marine life.
No attachments

Comment From: John Pauli

9/11/20 @ 7:45 AM
I do not support raising of hatchery steelhead in net pens in Puget Sound in any capacity.
Cooke Aquaculture and any other fish farming companies should be banned from Puget Sound permanently.
John Pauli,
President
4MSigma Corp. (VOSB--Wash St. Certified...↓
Cage: 0BC31
No attachments

Comment From: Janet Alderton

9/11/20 @ 7:04 AM
I am dismayed that public comments opposing aquaculture of finfish in confined feeding operations in our marine waters do not appear to have any effect on whether such negatively impactful projects are allowed to go forward. I agree with all the comm...↓
Must further legislation be adopted to specifically ban this new misguided proposal?
Attachments:

Comment From: Austin Franklin

9/11/20 @ 6:41 AM
I fully support the Cooke Aquaculture NPDES permit modification to change the species being raised in net pens. I believe they are trying to do things the right way and are making their operations as transparent as possible. The DOE is providing over...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Susan Alotrico

9/11/20 @ 6:10 AM
I do not support this project and neither can they pro e it will be safe. Farmed invasive species are already in the Salish seas from failed net pens. How wild species will survive interacting with farmed species is not know and I don't believe it s...↓

I vote NO!
No attachments

Comment From: Ben Bauermeister

9/11/20 @ 5:26 AM
Cooke does not have a reputation of being a good actor in this field. Their pens have collapsed, their pollution above regulated levels, and their responsiveness slow and recalcitrant. I believe that their application should be denied based on past...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Wendy Feltham

9/11/20 @ 4:34 AM
I have heard that Cooke Aquaculture hopes to switch from raising non-native salmon to steelhead trout in Puget Sound. I am writing strongly opposed to permitting Cooke Aquaculture to raise any kind of fish in their net pens or any other pens. Despite...↓

No attachments

Comment From: Katherine Scott

9/11/20 @ 4:07 AM
I'm appalled that this permit is even being considered.
Seriously?
Why would we trust Cooke Aquaculture now in view of their criminal past actions and the lies they told?
Mitigations may be made, good intentions may be promised, but pollution remains in...↓

No attachments

Comment From: Matthew Steinwurtzel

9/11/20 @ 3:59 AM
I strongly disapprove of the decision to allow Cooke Aquaculture to farm native steelhead in Puget Sound. For one, Cooke has proven that their track record in aquaculture does not support a healthy Puget Sound ecosystem, and they have proven that the...↓

Secondly, allowing Cooke Aquaculture to farm native steelhead works against a regional approach to restore our native populations of steelhead and other anadromous fish. With recent years of poor returns, this decision is incredibly concerning given how it will affect our wild fish.

I implore you to reject Cooke's permit and to focus on regional ecosystem-based solutions that will allow for the restoration of our prized fisheries.

Thank you for your time.
No attachments

Comment From: Jeffrey Norman

9/11/20 @ 3:54 AM
I am appalled that WSDOE would consider granting Cooke Aquaculture a permit to raise "Steelhead" in net pens. Steelhead are anadromous Rainbow Trout,
O. mykiss. What distinguishes it from its fluvial and lake-bound brethren is the sea-going life-cycle...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Terry Sullivan

9/11/20 @ 2:47 AM
Open water net pens for fish farming spread disease among wild fish, pollute the immediate environs, pose a threat to the genetic purity of local wild fish, and are not a solution to the environmental loss of local fish stocks. If we want to improve ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Neal Hoffberg

9/11/20 @ 2:40 AM
Cook Aquaculture nor any other artificial company should never be allowed to build new or maintain existing fish pens in the Puget Sound or other Northwest waters. Existing pens have already done irreparable damage to the environment and more import...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Penelope Benz

9/11/20 @ 1:36 AM
There is no reason in the world why a for-profit company should be able to lease a section of Puget Sound that belongs to the Public. I find it very offensive that ANY company can profit from using our public waterways. It should also be known that...↓

Any company wishing to grow fish should be required to purchase land and create their own fish pens- much like the Salmon Hatchery near Kingston.

Please DO NOT continue to allow this company or any other company to profit from using any part of Puget Sound!!
No attachments

Comment From: Charles Ballard

9/11/20 @ 1:25 AM
Net pens are never acceptable in Puget Sound waters as they concentrate droppings into a small area of the water and therefore pollution is concentrated . Steelhead are protected and in very short supply and should never be sold because people will b...↓

No attachments

Comment From: James Beck

9/10/20 @ 11:57 PM
I am very concerned about the waste produced by the massive number of fish raised and kept in net pens. There is no way for the massive amount of waste produced by the fish to be "flushed" out to sea, so it accumulates in the canals affecting water ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Megan Taylor

9/10/20 @ 11:56 PM
I am sad to see state agencies wasting yet more time trying to gather public input, review a plan, or insure that plan is followed by Cooke Aquaculture through monitoring by WA State agencies. They have been a very poor and irresponsible tenant in WA...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Mike Freeze

9/10/20 @ 9:06 PM
The use of all female sterile rainbow trout in Cooke's net pens is an excellent idea and should be permitted. This demonstrates Cooke Aquaculture's commitment to protecting the environment, while also providing much needed employment opportunities in...↓
No attachments

Comment From: christina conte

9/10/20 @ 10:05 AM
The Ft Ward fish pens are directly in our view and it's a shame that it's marred by them. I think our passage is much too narrow for the pens to be located here. They are a visual blight and the noise made by the operation is offensive. Not to mentio...↓

Recently I complained to the DNR, Fish & Wildlife, the Bainbridge Police and Cooke about the 100-200 sea lions that were hauling out on their pens for approximately 2 months this summer. All they needed to do was install more fencing to create a barrier. First they lied in an email to me and said it would cost $100K to fence the pens off. When several neighbors complained they installed simple fencing in 2 hours! But it took them months to respond and then act.

I'd like to see the passage returned to its indigenous state.
No attachments

Comment From: Jon Steeves

9/10/20 @ 1:17 AM
I approve and encourage growth of the aquaculture industry anywhere in the country, including these projects submitted by cooke aquaculture. we as a nation import 85%-90% of all seafood consumed and to not have our own production secured as a nation ...↓
Cooke though large in size has always operated in areas that often get forgotten or left behind, i suspect this will be no different and the areas of their operations will see an influx in demand to other local business and indirect spending by the business, its employees and other contractors and providers.
I fully support this growth industry and encourage governments country wide to get behind the industry to see it able to grow and become competitive with other nations.
No attachments

Comment From: Aileen Jeffries

9/09/20 @ 11:47 PM
The proposed continuation of net pens in the Puget Sound will have a detrimental effect to the marine ecosystem. The concentration of so many fish will promote fish disease, sea lice and contamination of the waters as well as many other negative effe...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Melissa Belz

9/09/20 @ 1:32 PM
I'm opposed to any net pens in WA. There is always change of escape, contamination, and use of antibiotics in the fish. Make habitat not pens.
Thank you
No attachments

Comment From: Steve Salonen

9/09/20 @ 12:00 PM
I do NOT want to see Cooke's steelhead pens in Puget Sound. Their poor track record of safety and containment of farmed fish is sufficient reason to deny their request.
No attachments

Comment From: Rob Schmaus

9/09/20 @ 11:20 AM
Please stop this!! If you had a house guest, and that house guest caused irreparable damage to your physical home, damage that could not be measured and who's repercussions will be felt for years, all because they directly defied you house rules, WHY...↓

It is absolutely ridiculous that This is even being considered...

These people have no respect of our waters, they have proven that. What has changed?

This is about money. Lobbyists and back door meetings. Don't let that sway you from doing what is so clearly right. STOP COOKE AQUACULTURE.

Renew the faith in our system and do what's right for our environment.

Bye Felicia!
No attachments

Comment From: Eleanor Mattice

9/09/20 @ 10:41 AM
Please do NOT allow fish farming in the Puget Sound. Fish farms pose a danger to native fish stocks with infections that are easily passed from the farmed fish. Please help our native salmon/steelhead fish improve their numbers.This, in turn, will he...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Jeff Waldron

9/09/20 @ 10:28 AM
This is still garbage. It is a permit to allow pollution from feed and fish feces. Reporting and monitoring does nothing to prevent the release of fish into a fragile environment. If Washington state cared about protecting natural resources such as s...↓
Easier to continue to limit salmon seasons and enforce closures while allowing private enterprises to utilize public resources to make a buck. Way to go Inslee minons or is that morons
No attachments

Comment From: William Fitzsimmons

9/09/20 @ 9:53 AM
If the truth is told you have a foreign corporation that wants to exploit a local resource for profit without knowing whether or not the presence of their facilities will have a deleterious effect on a cherished and valued environment. Cooke Aquacul...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Gerard Stromberg

9/09/20 @ 9:40 AM
Do not allow fish farming in our inland waters; Support salmon & steelhead hatchery programs.

No attachments

Comment From: Katherine Marshall

9/09/20 @ 9:13 AM
No! Please do not approve this reckless plan. Cooke Aquaculture has demonstrated its unreliability, it's past failure to follow rules it has agreed to, it's inability to keep its own operations from despoiling Puget Sound. I spend big parts of the y...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Andrew Stevenson

9/09/20 @ 8:53 AM
Lipstick on a pig. You continue to dance around the edges of the problems, instead of addressing them directly. Your statement that "the change from Atlantic salmon to steelhead is not likely to change the effect to water quality" is demonstrably fal...↓

NO NO NO!
No attachments

Comment From: Mike Brinkley

9/09/20 @ 8:21 AM
I am strongly against any kind of aquaculture in the sound. Feeding the fish depletes natural food sources and the waste products and disease from crowded net pens pollutes everything around the pens. Passing wild fish are adversely affected. the ...↓

NO NET PENS!!!!
No attachments

Comment From: William Bryden

9/09/20 @ 8:19 AM
The methods allowed by the permits are dated and do not reflect "best available technology to reduce impacts and wastage". Zero discharge land based RAS is available and must now be the new standard by which pollution acceptance is measured. Spill-ov...↓

PS I have an ecology degree and more than 10 years experience watch-dogging this method of protein reduction for profit. I have reviewed and testified during discharge permit applications in Maine and throughout Atlantic Canada as an expert witness. I have also been involved in numerous law-suits that I initiated and reviewed ALL of the open net pen EPR and EIS's filed in Atlantic Canada since 2012. In fact, most of them were triggered due to my work on this issue.
I can go on and on about predatory migration distruption and attraction, contagion amplification and increased virulence, a lack of effective monitoring, escapes and genetic introgression (triploidy is not 100%), effects of triploidy on salmonid health and predator preference/attraction, impacts from escapes, antibiotic/neurotoxin use/abuse and illegal toxin use by Cooke (multiple convictions), sea lice, claner fish abuse and disease/escapes/morts, coastal nutrification, etc All of which is avoided by RAS systems with zero effluent (eg the license-able tech offered by Sustainable Blue in NS Canada, and Superior Salmon in Wisconsin)
But will you even listen....will your grandchildren ever eat an economical wild salmon due to their abundance?
Be better than the managers before you....the ones that allowed and facilitated our current mess.
If you chose to ignore my warnings and pleas...at least fin mark or pitt tag every fish, allow eNGO over-sight for disease and lice monitoring, and set limits on lice and drug/toxin use, increase escape/disease/parasite monitoring and reporting...do it better and Cooke too will shift to land based....for the money.
No attachments

Comment From: L Wayne

9/09/20 @ 7:56 AM
Washington is the only state on the Pacific coast that permits these facilities. At the beginning of 2020, Canadian Prime Minister Trudeau announced plans to transition all open-water industrial aquaculture in British Columbia to land-based facilitie...↓

Many of these farmed fish would still be capable of interbreeding & exchanging pathogens & parasites with endangered wild Puget Sound steelhead. With this permit Cooke will be able to exploit a loophole in the legislative phaseout by raising steelhead rather than Atlantic salmon. Our state government needs legislation to get rid of any type of net pens! Our ocean, sea life, and the public's healthy consumption of fish is at risk.

No attachments

Comment From: Jean Thompson

9/09/20 @ 7:55 AM
I have continued concerns that Cooke Aquaculture can be relied upon to comply with the requirements of the permits they seek. It was non-compliance that led to the collapse of the Cypress Island pens and release of Atlantic Salmon, which we witnesse...↓

Additionally, I am not convinced there is a way to conduct aquaculture that does not pollute/harm the seabed below and the surrounding waters. Excess feed and concentrations of fish poo pile up on the seabed and smoother all naturally occurring living organisms.

Thirdly, I have seen multiple documentaries showing how fish farms attract an over population of sea lice. Whereby sea lice occur naturally, these concentrations attach to the smolt of wild fish runs in the area in numbers so great that they kill them before they reach the open sea, thereby reducing the survival rates of our wild fish runs.

Aqua culture is a threat to our wild fish runs and should not be allowed for anyone, anywhere.
No attachments

Comment From: Ryan Viers

9/09/20 @ 7:45 AM
Raising net pen Steelhead anywhere in the Pacific Northwest is an absolute disaster waiting to happen. Raising net pen Steelhead outside of the Skagit River watershed should have been shoot down long before it got to this stage.

The Skagit River was o...↓

Now lets rewind a couple years when Cooke had a net pen failure that saw tens of thousands of Atlantic Salmon (which are non-native to the Pacific Ocean and it's watersheds) swimming freely in the Sound and making their way up the Skagit River, as far as Rockport. A failure which by the way, Cooke tried to initially blame on big tides caused by an eclipse. Nice job on stepping up and taking ownership. Ultimately, if net pens with farmed Steelhead are allowed in Puget Sound outside of the Skagit River...it will fail, at some point. And, when it does fail all of those farmed Steelhead will do exactly what the Atlantic Salmon did, find a river to swim up. When that happens the farmed Steelhead will try to spawn with wild Steelhead. Maybe the farmed Steelhead are all sterile, that's what we are told anyway. But, how do we really know? A failure like this from a company that we already know tries to deflect responsibility could undo years, decades, of recovery of the fish that made the Skagit River known world wide.

Having farmed Steelhead on my plate is not a compelling enough argument to put a net pen, any net pens, in Puget Sound outside of the Skagit River. The state of Washington should not even be considering this. What should be considered is eliminating net pens altogether in Puget Sound, removing dams and hatcheries, and letting the fabled wild Salmon and Steelhead that made the Pacific Northwest what is, recover.
No attachments

Comment From: Scott Morrison

9/09/20 @ 7:38 AM
I am concerned for water quality and fish diseases. Caged cultured fish are susepable to many different fish discease and parasites, and my concerns are for wild fish, during all of their life stages, that may swim near these structures, could get ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Joseph Jauquet

9/09/20 @ 7:25 AM
The first three items in your revisions above address escape, and the remaining three address pollution and net maintenance. This implicitly acknowledges the major problems you and Cooke expect from the so-called revised plans. Thus, one or more of...↓

I am strongly opposed to any net pens by any entity for any specie(s) anywhere in WA waters, including the San Juans and the open Straits. I am completely disappointed with WDFW (a former employer) and DOE for not understanding the spirit of the law and rejecting the net pen application forthwith.

Thank you for your consideration,
J. Jauquet
No attachments

Comment From: Kristopher Johansen

9/09/20 @ 7:10 AM
No Net-Pens of any kind in Washington State!

Net-Pens are not environmentally friendly, even ones with Native species being raised.

If we want more Salmon, manage the populations better. Reduce/cut the quota, close more fisheries for longer periods of ...↓

Encourage people to eat less Salmon, so we HAVE more Salmon.
No attachments

[ Previous Page / Next Page ]