Cooke Aquaculture Pacific NPDES permits modifications to raise steelhead

152 Results

Sort:

Comment From: Anonymous Anonymous

10/26/20 @ 3:59 PM
Wild Salmon Nation Supports Wild Salmon and Habitat from Baja to the Bering Sea.

After reviewing the inadequacies of Washington State's Department of Ecology's modifications to the existing NPDES permits for Cooke's former salmon farms, enabling Cooke...↓

1. Cooke Aquaculture Pacific is not a responsible corporate citizen, they have continually broken Washington State's trust through their negligent actions, lack of maintenance, and escapes. They are a bad actor and should not be rewarded with more opportunity to profit further off of Public Waters that belong "in common" with all Washington State Citizens

2. Self-Regulation and Self-Reporting by Cooke? Seriously, with their track record? 3 Strikes and you're out, or does Cooke keep getting more at bats, and more tries to embarrass the Department of Ecology?

3. Transfer of Viruses and Diseases from concentrated feedlot farmed animals to local waters, and native fish populations.

4. Marking- Farmed Fish need to be physically marked, so that they can be identified from Wild Steelhead populations if they escape.
-to be marked so as to distinguish an aquaculture-raised steelhead from conventional hatchery-raised steelhead and from wild, natural-origin, steelhead. It is critical that aquaculture-raised steelhead be provided with an externally visible mark that is distinct from the adipose clip used to identify conventional hatchery-reared steelhead.

5. Ecology needs to focus on the net-pen waste and feces stream, and its attractant implications as an unnatural pesticide, pharmaceutical, and antibiotic-laden food source for at-risk and struggling Puget Sound herring and forage fish populations, immature salmonids, and Native Steelhead smolts.

6. We are also concerned with the potential for attracted forage fish, immature salmonids, and Native Steelhead smolts, to become trapped residents in the pens, and a "take" from the Public Commons as an added "free" food source for the Cooke fish farms.
This has been well-documented through the use of underwater cameras in British Columbia aquaculture operations.

7. The other concern is the transfer of sea lice parasites from the swarms that develop and expand at the farms, to wild and resident fish populations. Low-count lice loading has been proven to be detrimental and fatal to immature salmonids, forage fish, and Native Steelhead smolts. Just a few sea lice can induce mortality in smolts.

8. Floating Concentrated Feed Lots are endangering the health of Washington's waters which support our culture, economy, wild salmon, and killer whales.

9. Jobs. A few hundred jobs for Cooke, versus tens of thousands that rely intact habitat, healthy clean water, and Wild Native Fish Populations.

No attachments

Comment From: Jon Russell

10/26/20 @ 3:55 PM
Why grant these permits to CAP when time and time again they have broken trust through negligent actions, lack of maintenance and allowing escapes to occur? They are a bad actor and to give this permit is to make negligence permissible. And further, ...↓

Allowing farmed steelheads and trout to be added will almost certainly cause vast harms to the wild populations and the surrounding environment. It's well documented that feedlot fed farmed fish are extremely dangerous when they escape due to viruses, diseases, and transfer of parasites.

It is extremely dangerous and negligent to allow this permit for Cooke Aquaculture Pacific
No attachments

Comment From: Alexandra Gayek

10/26/20 @ 2:20 PM
I urge you to reject this proposal by Cooke Aquaculture. I am not in favor of farmed fish in our oceans. Regardless of species, the process of farming creates pollution, breeds disease, attracts sea lice, and results in a product that is less healthy...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Spike Mafford

10/26/20 @ 2:07 PM
The inadequacies of Washington State's Department of Ecology's modifications to the existing NPDES permits for Cooke's former salmon farms, enabling Cooke to switch to Triploid Steelhead/Trout,are overwhelming. We strongly urge the Department of Ecol...↓
Here are a few things to consider:

Cooke Aquaculture Pacific is not a responsible citizen, they have continually broken Washington State's trust through their negligent actions, lack of maintenance, and escapes. They are a bad actor and should not be rewarded with more opportunity to profit again off Public Waters.
Transfer of Viruses and Diseases from concentrated feedlot farmed animals to local waters, and native fish populations.
Farmed Fish need to be physically marked, so that they can be identified from Wild Steelhead populations if they escape.
-to be marked so as to distinguish an aquaculture-raised steelhead from conventional hatchery-raised steelhead and from wild, natural-origin, steelhead. It is critical that aquaculture-raised steelhead be provided with an externally visible mark that is distinct from the adipose clip used to identify conventional hatchery-reared steelhead.
Ecology needs to focus on the net-pen waste and feces stream, and its attractant implications as an unnatural pesticide, pharmaceutical, and antibiotic-laden food source for at-risk and struggling Puget Sound herring and forage fish populations, immature salmonids, and Native Steelhead smolts.
I am also concerned with the potential for attracted forage fish, immature salmonids, and Native Steelhead smolts, to become trapped residents in the pens, and a "take" from the Public Commons as an added "free" food source for the Cooke fish farms.
This has been well-documented through the use of underwater cameras in British Columbia aquaculture operations.
The other concern is the transfer of sea lice parasites from the swarms that develop and expand at the farms, to wild and resident fish populations. Low-count lice loading has been proven to be detrimental and fatal to immature salmonids, forage fish, and Native Steelhead smolts.
Floating Feed Lots are endangering the health of Washington's waters which support our culture, economy, wild salmon, and Orca whales.
Save the Sound, the whales and the wild salmon from this predatory practice.
No attachments

Comment From: Cooke Aquaculture Pacific (Jim Parsons)

10/26/20 @ 1:55 PM
Please see attached comment file. Thank you.
Attachments:

Comment From: Gregg Dunphy

10/26/20 @ 11:32 AM
Please see the attached file sent on behalf of the Lummi Natural Resources Department Director
Attachments:

Comment From: ProFish International Inc (Walter Pereyra)

10/26/20 @ 11:06 AM
My comment letter is attached in the uploaded files (2 pages)
Attachments:

Comment From: Our Sound, Our Salmon (Kurt Beardslee)

10/26/20 @ 10:53 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: Aquatic Life Institute (Rebecca Jenkins)

10/26/20 @ 10:22 AM
Public Comment on Revised Water Quality Permits from Washington State Department of Ecology

General Introduction

The following comment is submitted on behalf of a coalition of animal welfare advocates, animal welfare lawyers, and nonprofit organization...↓

The below comment raises concerns regarding the revised water quality permits in question. Our main concern is aquatic animal welfare (for animals both within and outside such net pens), as we believe animal welfare is both an issue of importance in and of itself and that, in many cases such as this, improved animal welfare (e.g. appropriate stocking density, responsible feeding practices, good fish health) can lead to improved water quality impacts (and vice versa).

We would like to thank the Washington State Department of Ecology for the opportunity to comment on Cooke Aquaculture's NPDES permit application to raise partially sterile, triploid steelhead trout in lieu of Atlantic salmon. This coalition hopes that the Washington State Department of Ecology will adequately consider the existing scientific evidence that these floating feedlots may impact wild, endangered steelhead trout, salmon, and Southern Resident Killer Whales, and may impact surrounding water quality and the overall health of Puget Sound.

The Issue at Hand
We are concerned that rather than conducting a robust, current, and accurate impacts analysis for the issues outlined below, WDFW largely relied on stale information from a decades-old programmatic environmental impact statement for fish culture in net pens from January 1990, which did not provide mitigation measures that adequately minimize significant environmental impacts. Furthermore, the 5th Circuit's recent ruling that aquaculture isn't fishing and can't be regulated as such further supports the idea that a serious SEPA analysis is required for NPDES reviews in this setting.
Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife's (WDFW) decision not to issue an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for Cooke Aquaculture (and the "analysis" upon which that decision was based) has deprived the public of information and the opportunity to meaningfully participate, as required by statute. Were WDFW to act in accordance with law, the process could further efforts to protect fish populations, their habitat, and the surrounding water quality. The State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA) is a procedural statute designed to ensure that decision makers in the State of Washington properly consider the environmental impacts of their decisions, to ensure humankind and the environment continue in harmony. SEPA requires an agency to conduct a "threshold determination" that analyzes whether the project has a probable, significant adverse environmental impact. If the agency makes a determination of significance, it must prepare a thorough EIS that includes analysis of reasonable alternatives that achieve similar goals with less environmental impact. Environmental impacts include factors such as impacts to fish and wildlife, plants and animals, surface water quality and runoff, aesthetics, recreation, scenic resources, and historical and cultural preservation.
The threshold determination is the initial SEPA assessment and "must indicate that the agency has taken a searching, realistic look at the potential hazards and, with reasoned thought and analysis, candidly and methodically addressed those concerns."
Important environmental repercussions include, but are not limited to: the unforeseeable impacts of climate change, warming waters, and their chemical interactions; the impacts from net pen pollution to the benthic community, plants, and animals in nearby waters; the impacts from poor escape prevention and net hygiene practices, including impacts from pen sinking; the impacts from escapements of farm-raised steelhead on wild steelhead genetics, wild salmonids' prey and habitat, and wild salmonids' predators (including the impacts of any recovery efforts or decisions); the impacts of farmed steelhead diseases, pathogens, and parasites on native species; the impacts on native species and the environment of chemicals and pharmaceuticals used to rear farmed steelhead; the impacts on native species of farmed steelhead that are not successfully sterilized; the impacts of harvest efforts, including water withdrawals, discharges and bycatch, on native species and the environment; and the air and noise pollution impacts on adjacent lands and landowners.

Specific Issues of Concern
In the present case, we have identified several concerns that directly relate to water quality degradation and fish welfare including disease, waste, feed, and escapes. Diligent monitoring and reporting is of utmost importance in the following areas:
Disease:
We are concerned about disease outbreaks, both because of welfare concerns impacting animals within and outside the pen(s), and other environmental impacts.
Best welfare management practices (lower stocking density, responsible feed composition, etc.) while fish are cultured in marine waters can reduce stress, thereby reducing risk of infection, disease amplification, and transmission. Traditional vaccinations prepare the individual organisms' immune systems to combat pathogens, and to reduce the risks of infection, pathogen amplification and transmission, and disease. Cooke anticipates using a subset of the suite of vaccines used for Atlantic salmon for their production of all-female triploid steelhead trout.
A May 2020 report from the Fish Welfare Initiative surveying welfare issues in Atlantic salmon aquaculture found that pesticide-resistant sea lice present an existential threat to the salmon farming industry and represent an extinction-level threat to wild salmon populations. We support the careful use of preventative measures to maintain fish health where possible, and careful antibiotic usage only where absolutely necessary, as prescribed by and used under the guidance of an experienced and licensed fish veterinarian.
Cooke Aquaculture claims that they preserve fish health through a warm water sea lice removal system and stock cleaner fish with salmon to minimize impact of sea lice. We are very concerned about the welfare implications of cleaner fish usage. The use of anti-sea lice pesticides must be closely regulated under a NPDES Aquatic Pesticide/Fisheries Resource Management Permit. State and federal law requires coverage under an aquatic pesticide permit for all activities that involve the use of pesticides or nutrient-inactivation products for managing aquatic organisms in waters of the state. All aquatic pesticide permits regulate the amounts and types of pesticide products, as well as when, where, and how these products can be applied. These permits also provide critical details on the specific monitoring, reporting, and public notification requirements for products used. Therefore, an updated EIS should be required in order to determine if Cooke's pest management activities can continue without causing irreparable harm.

Waste:

As in terrestrial animal agriculture, waste management is a crucial environmental consideration.
Ammonia is the most important waste product from the metabolism of proteins in fish. It is determined as Total Ammonia Nitrogen and expresses the sum of ionised NH4 and unionized (gas) NH3. It is important to stress that unionised ammonia never exists alone but will act in synergy with other contaminants. The distribution of the two forms is highly dependent on pH, temperature, and salinity. NH3 is one of the most toxic forms due to its high membrane permeability. Concentrations of 25 �g to 300 �g NH3/L have been reported to cause mortality in salmonid fishes, and 10 �g NH3/L is known to cause negative gill interaction. Negative effects on plasma cortisone, plasma catecholamine, respiration, osmoregulation, circulation, haematology, and histology of gills, kidney, and liver as a result of higher levels have been observed (Smart 1978; U.S. EPA 1989; Alabaster and Lloyd 1982).
The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has set a maximum 1 Hr exposure per every third year of wild fish to 5000 �g Total Ammonia Nitrogen/L at a pH of 8.0, and 2500 �g Total Ammonia Nitrogen/L at a pH of 8.5. Toxicity of ammonia increases in hypoxic conditions (Alabaster and Lloyd 1982). Additionally, high pH and increased transformation of NH4 to NH3 result in the increased toxicity of NH3 in seawater (Girard & Payan, 1980).
While it is difficult to give exact upper safe limits for water chemistry parameters since many of the parameters interact in a complicated manner, ammonia poisoning can be avoided by keeping the pH to a safe level, suggested to be in lower limit range (6.2 � 6. 5) and avoid rapid pH rise due to intake of new water volumes with higher pH, in addition to keeping dissolved oxygen close to 100%. However, such exact measurements are very difficult to keep track of in open net pens, and therefore are virtually impossible to regulate and subsequently provide accurate reports in these facilities. It is imperative to understand and adjust the quality of water according to the species-specific needs of the fish in order to protect their welfare, ensure optimal health, and preserve water quality as a result.
Discharges of excess nutrients, particularly nitrogen, into Puget Sound from domestic wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) are contributing to low oxygen levels in Puget Sound. As these WWTPs are contributing human sources of excess nutrients to Puget Sound, the state must take action to control this pollution. On Jan. 30, 2020, The Dept. of Ecology announced their decision to move forward with developing a draft Nutrients General Permit for Puget Sound. The proposed Nutrients General Permit would apply to all facilities discharging to marine and estuarine waters of Puget Sound. The overall nutrient discharge from such open net aquaculture facilities should also be considered under this new initiative.

Chum:
We are also concerned about the impacts of uneaten feed which could act as "chum".
The information provided by Cooke about fish feed consumption rates and the amount of excess feed spilling out of the net pen facility is unsatisfactory.
Cooke provided an estimate of the monthly fish feed at maximum production (Cooke 2020). However, a more useful fish feed report should aim to provide an estimate of the amount of feed that goes uneaten. This uneaten fish food that falls through the net pen into surrounding waters is a recurring discharge that attracts native fish as well as predatory birds and pinnipeds. This excess chum is an open invitation to wildlife with deadly consequences, as increased entrapments are bound to occur. Effects of predator control is an ongoing global conservation concern, with potentially significant impacts for several key species and populations. Until the Dept. of Ecology establishes with reasonable certainty the amount of fish feed released from the net pen facility, it cannot perform an adequate assessment of the adverse impacts to water quality and animal welfare.
Cooke has implemented a new feeding system designed to ensure the fish are fed steadily at certain amounts, while also eliminating any feed waste. However, there is no mention about the differing feed conversion rates between Atlantic salmon and steelhead trout. Atlantic salmon are generally more efficient at converting feed to biomass than trout are, with trout being more variable in feed conversion rates and more susceptible to environmental controls (temperature and salinity) on growth (Fry 2018).
The Department of Ecology issues Concentrated Animal Feeding Operation (CAFO) General Permits to operations that confine livestock for long periods of time in pens or barns and discharge pollution to surface or groundwater. This same nature and degree of consideration should extend to net pens due to the fact that their excess feed directly contributes to pollution discharge.
Furthermore, from an aquatic animal welfare perspective and sustainability perspective, we support research efforts to try to reduce the amount of wild-caught fish being used for fish farm feed. ALI has recently estimated that approximately 1.2 trillion fish are reduced to fishmeal/fish oil each year, contributing to ocean degradation, abandoned fishing gear, and death of endangered species .

Escape:
Unfortunately, net pen escapes are well documented worldwide.
After the Cypress net pen collapsed in 2017, research discovered that nearly every fish that escaped was infected with a pathogenic exotic salmon virus that had been undetected and unreported.
There was a structural failure of a net pen facility located in Cypress Island, resulting in the discharge of a quarter-million farmed Atlantic salmon, dead fish carcasses, and massive amounts of debris, among other pollutants. These discharges represent violations of the NPDES permits under which Cooke Aquaculture's Atlantic salmon net pens currently operate, and will continue to operate regardless of the species being reared.
Escapes could increase stress levels among captive fish, pose significant health risks to wild fish, and degrade water quality, which would have a negative effect on all fish welfare.
The fact that the steelhead in question will be partially sterile only mitigates some of the various concerns which have been raised by all too frequent escapes in Washington, the U.S and around the world in recent years. From a welfare perspective, and potentially a health, disease and water quality perspective, we have some concerns about triploid fish. This is an area in which considerable knowledge gaps exist. While more research is needed, Norweigan studies show that these fish appear "more susceptible to temperature stress and have a higher incidence of deformities"
Cooke stated they are going to "update the comprehensive Operational Procedures for Fish Escape Prevention, Reporting and Recapture and Regulated Fish Pathogen Reporting and Biosecurity Plans" on their SEPA environmental checklist. While we commend these efforts, relying on such future promises is inadequate given the high risks at stake when trying to preserve and protect the region and all parties involved.
Conclusions
NPDES permits protect water quality by restricting pollution and requiring monitoring, reporting, and utilization of best management practices. Improved protections and requirements to reduce environmental impacts from net pen operations could include: increasing underwater video monitoring; conducting regular inspections to assess structural integrity of the net pens and submitting inspection reports certified by an objective third party; requiring improved maintenance and cleaning of the net pens, water quality monitoring, and maintenance procedures; requiring transparent reporting if fish mortality rate exceeds 0.5 - 1% (rather than the proposed 5%)); refraining from self-reporting and instead relying on a third party to assess and disclose pertinent information; developing site-specific response plans for implementation in the event that fish escape; conducting and participating in emergency preparedness training; and maintaining contact information to promptly notify area tribes and state agencies in the event of an escape.
In order for the Department of Ecology to perform its duty to ensure that discharges will not endanger water quality, human health, or the environment, the Department should conduct a thorough analysis of Cooke's application and engage in its own SEPA analysis to determine if the NPDES permit should be granted without a new threshold determination.

References:
Alabaster, J.S. and Lloyd. R. 1982. Water quality criteria for freshwater fish. 2nd edition. Butterworth Scientific, London. 361 sider.
Cooke January 2020 NPDES permit application, p. 9.
Fry, J., et al 2018 Environ. Res. Lett. 13 024017
Girard J.P and P. Payan (1980) Ion exchange through respiratory and chloride cells in freshwater and seawater adapted teleosts. Am. J. Physiol. 238, R260-R268.
Smart, G. 1978. Investigations of the toxic mechanisms of ammonia to fish-gas exchange in rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri) exposed to acutely lethal concentrations. J. Fish. Biol. 12, 93-104.
U.S. EPA 1990. Ambient water quality criteria for ammonia (saltwater)-1989 EPA 440/5-88-004, Office of Water Regulations and Standards Division, Washington D.C.

Signatories:
Aquatic Life Institute
Fish Welfare Initiative
Animal Equality
Center for Chilean Animal Law Studies
Professor. Kathy Hessler (Director of The Aquatic Animal Law Initiative)

Attachments:

Comment From: Orca Conservancy (Shari Tarantino)

10/26/20 @ 10:16 AM
Please add the following two attachments to the administrative record on behalf of Orca Conservancy.
Attachments:

Comment From: Rich Passage Estates Homeowner... (Kathleen Hansen)

10/26/20 @ 9:17 AM
Rich Passage Estates Homeowners' Association
Bainbridge Island, Washington

The attached documents provide public comments by the Rich Passage Estates Homeowners' Association related to the application by Cooke Aquaculture for National Pollutant Dischar...↓

Attachments:

Comment From: Hugh Mitchell

10/26/20 @ 8:21 AM
Comments attached in a pdf.
Attachments:

Comment From: Tom Hansen

10/26/20 @ 8:07 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: Jules Michel

10/26/20 @ 7:31 AM
Summary: It is premature to issue discharge permits to Cooke Aquaculture's proposed open net pens growing mostly sterile rainbow trout in Puget Sound until EPA and NOAA have completed their Biological Opinion, started only due to a court decision. Is...↓

Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the proposed discharge permits which would allow Cooke Aquaculture to grow mostly sterile rainbow trout in Puget Sound and create plumes of untreated waste discharged into Puget Sound's public waters.

As background, I was born, raised and educated in Washington State. My family has owned property on the shoreline of Puget Sound for four generations now. I have seen development along the shoreline, in the tidelands and in the waters evolve over those many years to levels not considered in the past.

There is no question that aquaculture has been largely ignored until recently, most believing it is benign with little to no adverse impacts. The recent court case which negated the Corps of Engineers Nationwide Permit 48 clearly demonstrates cumulative impacts have not been considered adequately, whether in the form of shellfish aquaculture or in this case net pen aquaculture. The more recent court decision which forced NOAA and the EPA to begin a Bilogical Opinion should shine a bright enough light on this process to show the Department of Ecology it is premature to consider, let alone issue any discharge permits to Cooke Aquaculture, no matter the species grown.

The press release from Wild Fish Conservancy summarizes adequately that decision and process, found here: https://wildfishconservancy.org/pressrelease10.11.2018/at_download/file

Thank you for the opportunity to comment and to help protect Puget Sound.
No attachments

Comment From: Marcia Lagerloef

10/26/20 @ 7:17 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: Judith Akins

10/26/20 @ 6:49 AM
Ms. Laurie Niewolny
Permit Lead and Acquisition Specialist
Washington State Department of Ecology
PO Box 47600
Olympia, WA 98504
Email: laurie.niewolny@ecy.wa.gov

Re: Cooke Aquaculture Pacific, LLC NPDES permit modification application.

Dear Ms. Niewolny,

Th...↓

While the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife has approved this project under SEPA, stating that the proposal "does not warrant an Environmental Impact Statement and the proposal will likely not have significant adverse impacts on the environment",I question the non-significance of this aquaculture project. I believe there will be significant impacts to the Puget Sound by these four projects and one only has to look at the comments already submitted by The Wild Fish Conservancy, Skagit Audubon Society, Swinomish Indian Tribal Community, Evergreen Islands, Our Sound Our Salmon.

Looking at the additional requirements being placed on Cooke I find some statements which are troubling. In the modifications DOE is requiring Cooke to prohibit release. Was not Cooke also charged with this prohibition when in August 2017, they allowed 250,000 salmon to escape and did not report this incident until days later? They are required to report unusual events, Cooke had a highly "unusual event" occur in 2017 and they did not report it until after others had reported seeing the Atlantic Salmon in their nets.

Fish feeding is an issue and the requirement that Cooke increase their monitoring, however they do not plan any changes in their feeding program. Fish feed along with the antibiotics are a very real threat to our native species and the surrounding waters. Farmed triploid rainbow trout are fed antibiotics which are widely used in modern aquaculture to prevent or treat bacterial diseases in farmed fish. The Seafood Watch program suggests that people should only eat these fish from indoor recirculating tanks because of levels of these antibiotics etc. in the fish.

Ecology has required Cooke to follow AKART analysis (All Known Available and Reasonable Methods of Treatment) to avoid excessive accumulation of marine growth.This contribution to marine waters of eutrophication, feces and uneaten food pellets alter the organic matter in the sediment, which can change the consumption of oxygen and can cause local eutrophication. According to the Institute For Coastal Marine Environment, "The most common negative environmental effect is water eutrophication, water quality, and transmission of animal diseases." (Monique Mancuso, Institute for Coastal Marine Environment (IAMC) www.journaloffisheries.com ) This can cause changes in the abundance and composition of microflora. The eutrophication causes dense growth of plant life and death of animal life and the spread and outbreak of diseases.Studies by both Ecology and WDFW: the 2000 Seventh Report of the Puget Sound Ambient Update finds "Widespread evidence of the declining population of Puget Sound marine organisms suggests the importance of new efforts to protect and recover populations. Recovery plans based on an ecosystem perspective will require additional information about the specific relationships among various Puget Sound species and the influences of various natural and human-caused environmental stresses on marine populations."WA State is spending millions of dollars for salmon recovery which depends on healthy seas. Continued fish aquaculture by Cooke and their proven record of abuse will only continue the decline to these waters.

Cooke is being required to improve their Net Hygiene in accordance with DNR protocol. Although Cooke has been required to do so, it has not maintained and cleaned net pens in the past and allowed buildup of mussels and other marine organisms which led to the net pen collapse in August 2017. The Department of Natural Resources report on Cooke's net pen collapse states that the net pens were not properly designed. (Negligence caused August net pen collapse News Date January 30, 2018, dnr.wa.gov) and as Cooke is making no changes to their structures the possibility of another collapse is real.

As government agencies address the effects of fish-farming in the Puget Sound waters, there is almost no scientific evidence that supports that this a healthy addition to our marine waters and in fact there is much evidence that supports that fish aquaculture contributes to the detriment of our water quality and life within the marine environment. It is my belief that Land-based Recirculating Aquaculture Systems (RAS) are a far better alternative for aquaculture farms. These systems located upland, allow for fin fish aquaculture but would greatly reduce or eliminate the impacts to the marine environment caused by net pens.

While "WDFW has determined that this proposal will likely not have a significant adverse impact on the environment", science is proving that this proposal will have significant adverse impacts to the marine environment and waters of Puget Sound. WA State is spending millions of dollars for salmon recovery which depends on healthy seas. Continued fish aquaculture by Cooke and their proven record of abuse will only continue the decline to these waters. We must study any and all impacts of any industry that will affect the Salish Sea and cannot allow any industry to threaten an already threatened environment and do further harm. I strongly urge that a new permit process be conducted on these projects and ones that include new SEPA analysis, threshold determination and a public hearing.

I am looking forward to seeing that the Department of Ecology carefully consider all the comments and decide in favor of a healthy and viable Puget Sound.

No attachments

Comment From: Jamestown S'Klallam Tribe (Hansi Hals)

10/26/20 @ 6:04 AM
On behalf of Jamestown S'Klallam Tribe, I am submitting this letter from Tribal Chair/CEO Ron Allen regarding the NPDES permit modifications for Cooke Aquaculture's net pen facilities in marine WA waters. Thank you, Hansi Hals
Attachments:

Comment From: Stephanie Ross

10/26/20 @ 5:55 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: Wild Steelhead Coalition (Gregory Topf)

10/26/20 @ 5:52 AM
(Document uploaded)
Attachments:

Comment From: Suquamish Tribe (Thomas Ostrom)

10/26/20 @ 4:43 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: Friends of the Earth (Hallie Templeton)

10/26/20 @ 2:11 AM
Please accept the attached comments from 1093 members and activists of Friends of the Earth who are opposed to the issuance of the proposed water quality permits for Cooke Aquaculture to raise steelhead trout in its existing net pens. Friends of the ...↓

Thank you for accepting and considering these comments.
Attachments:

Comment From: Northwest Aquaculture Alliance (Jeanne McKnight)

10/25/20 @ 11:40 PM
October 26, 2020

Laurie Niewolny, Water Quality Program
Washington State Department of Ecology
P.O. Box 47600
Olympia, WA 98504

Re: Comments on Ecology Draft Permit Modifications for Cooke Aquaculture Pacific

Dear Ms. Niewolny:

The Northwest Aquaculture Al...↓

First and foremost, we are pleased that the agency has correctly concluded, based on best available science from leading researchers from the public and the private sector, that little or no difference exists in feed utilization and nutrient waste production between Atlantic salmon and rainbow trout/steelhead. This finding of fact should clear the way for a swift granting of permits so that this company can get back to doing what it does best: Producing high-quality, high-value, nutritious seafood for human consumption, creating well-paying jobs along the way.

At the same time, however, we urge the Department of Ecology to use restraint by not requiring CAP or any company in a similar situation to divulge proprietary information to the state. We see this as a dangerous precedent, and we respectfully request that the agency avoid adding additional new requirements or constraints on this company's existing permits.

We are all aware that there are very vocal groups in this state that do not support having net pens in state waters. However, it should be noted that commercial net pen aquaculture has been going on in Washington waters for more than 30 years. Today, in fact, several tribes are growing salmon for their delayed release fish enhancement projects by using net pens in the early life stages of their fish.

Technology has made this form of farming—in the water—the most sustainable, environmentally friendly form of food production of all types of protein production. As the federal government works toward its vision of farming in the open ocean, and seafood companies look to both offshore aquaculture as well as experimental land-based fish growing operations, the reality is that marine aquaculture worldwide remains one of the most efficient, environmentally responsible, and sustainable ways to produce the protein the world needs.

As our organization's diverse membership shows,the business of aquaculture is heavily dependent on science. To grow any kind of finfish (or shellfish), growers rely heavily upon science—including genetics, breeding, animal health, veterinary medicine, and nutrition, to name just a few areas of study.

It is also heavily reliant on technology, including but not limited to the use of computers and underwater cameras that make sure no feed is being wasted to robotics to GPS systems. Companies like Cooke continue to embrace new technologies that help grow much-needed protein more efficiently, allowing producers to monitor the fish growing process through their entire life cycle.

In addition, feed companies have also embraced innovation, creating fish feeds that minimize the use of marine ingredients, increase the digestibility, and meet the exact nutritional requirements of the fish stocks at each stage of the growth cycle. We have come a long way as an industry and companies in our organization—particularly CAP in this instance—are leading the way in being stewards of the environment.

Finally, if the COVID-19 pandemic has taught us anything, it is that we as a state, region, and country need to put ourselves in the position of being food secure. That means, among other things, "growing our own" rather than importing. It means encouraging the development of rural natural resource jobs, of taking pride in what we grow in Washington's lands and waters.

Aquaculture is the future, and we in Washington are at a crossroads. We can either lead, follow, or get out of the way and let our food come from other countries where regulations may not be as stringent as those in the United States. There is no reason the United States cannot cultivate its own seafood resources and businesses right here at home in our own waters.

Because Washington state has done extensive research and monitoring of net pen operations in the state, and because current regulations on any discharges from net pen operations are among of world's most stringent, we are hopeful that Cooke Aquaculture Pacific will be granted the permits it seeks to begin to supply local and regional markets once again.

On behalf of our fish and shellfish grower members as well as the many companies involved in supplying our producers, we urge you to take a broad view of this request and grant Cooke Aquaculture Pacific the permits to begin operating, and to do so in an expeditious manner.

Thank you.

Sincerely,

Jeanne McKnight, Ph.D.
Executive Director
Northwest Aquaculture Alliance
P.O. Box 8562
Covington, Washington 98042 USA

No attachments

Comment From: Global Aquaculture Alliance (Steve Hedlund)

10/25/20 @ 4:00 PM
Attachments:

Comment From: Maradel Gale

10/25/20 @ 3:07 PM
Puget Sound and the Salish Sea have had enough of industrial aquaculture, especially finfish netpens. These are loci of parasites, pesticides, fecal material and basically incompatible with the protection of our marine waters. Cooke Aquaculture sho...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Anonymous Anonymous

10/25/20 @ 11:23 AM
Ms. Laura Watson and the Washington State Department of Ecology,
Due to past malpractice and negligence Cooke Aquaculture should be denied a Pacific NPDES permit modification to raise steelhead.
I am vehemently opposed to the continuation of this proje...↓

No attachments

Comment From: Stephen O'Brien

10/25/20 @ 11:16 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: Rachel Running

10/25/20 @ 8:48 AM
I am adamantly opposed to the permit modification that would allow Cooke to change species
from Atlantic salmon to steelhead. It is unfathomable that Cooke's past practices with raising
Atlantic salmon is not being considered. They have consistently pu...↓
being in compliance with environment standards. The only oversight of the Bainbridge Island net
pens seems to come from the neighborhood, questioning what they are doing, calling them out on
it and at times reporting them. Clearly the pens are in a state of disrepair. When one of the
pontoons had a leak over several days the pen became lower and lower in the water. They were
notified yet nothing was done until it was reported to the coastguard. By that time a corner was
submerged. My family consistently picks up trash/debris from the beach that appears to come from
the farm. We have had issues with noise from generators that are suppose to have noise abatement
covers on them, pressure washing, and fish die off. We have witnessed seals and a sea lion in the
pens eating fish. If they get in surely salmon are getting out. There were hundreds of sea lions residing on one set of pens for 8 months before any abatement was done.
Just last month they put old nets in an open dumpster for a weekend. It caused an unbearable stench throughout the neighborhood. After a complaint was made someone came and at least put a tarp over the dumpster. There have been multiple such instances. How can this company be trusted. Their past practices must be considered when modifying any permit. What would make them take any more
care with this new endeavor, who will oversee this. Clearly they have not been good stewards in
caring for the puget sound and a new species wouldn't change that.
The pending litigation needs to be resolved before the company is allowed to move forward on this.
Thank you
Rachel Running
No attachments

Comment From: Karen McDonell

10/25/20 @ 8:39 AM
Net pens cause discharges of effluent that flows down into Puget Sound and they must be shut down. I live on a shellfish farm in the lower Sound and we have had catastrophic clam die-offs in each of the last two years from discharges from fish pens ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Helen Frances Glass

10/25/20 @ 6:27 AM
I fully support the denial of NPDES permit modifications and any further attempts to support Net Pen Fishing in our public waters. As many neighbors and citizens have already spoken so eloquently on the subject in the comments already received, I wil...↓
When I first moved to the Fort Ward neighborhood in 2018, I was astonishes to see that our Rich Passage waters were home to Orchard Rocks "Conservation Area" and Fort Ward Underwater Park "marine protected area". How then, could this fish farm exist right next to them?
And when observing the view from Google Earth, I was even more alarmed to see the clouds of waste and feces being transported directly to these sights by our strong incoming/high tides. For a population who seems committed to the "conservation" message and makes such efforts to pick up pet waste, spend a bit extra on green cleaning, laundry and gardening products, earnest about what goes down a storm drain and mortified by the thought of a sewage treatment mishap, I was shocked to see that we could watch the flushing of this giant toilet full of untreated waste each and every day in front of our own eyes.
It seemed so farcical at the time. What do we want to support and subsidize with our tax dollars?
I hope we will close the SEPA loop hole and end the Farce of thinking Net Pen Fishing and Conservation of out waters can ever be compatible.

Thank you for the opportunity to comment,

Frances Glass
No attachments

Comment From: Douglas Love

10/25/20 @ 5:13 AM
What may have been a good idea 30 years ago is no longer a good idea. Because farming salmon and other fish in tanks on land is now a viable, commercially profitable alternative to fish pens in open water, continuing to permit the farming of fish in...↓

If Cooke's modification request is granted, the State should not allow Cooke to continue farming fish of any type past 2022, with 2023 and 2024 used by them to remove the pens, remove or close facilities, and monitor environmental conditions in the area.
No attachments

Comment From: Cyndy Holtz

10/23/20 @ 11:25 PM
Please see uploaded file.
Attachments:

Comment From: Swinomish Indian Tribal Commun... (Amy Trainer)

10/23/20 @ 7:43 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: RE Sources (Kirsten McDade)

10/23/20 @ 2:14 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: anonymous anonymous

10/23/20 @ 1:54 AM
This request is ONLY for a modification to the species being raised. The proposed change to raise native, sterile, steelhead trout is very reasonable, and I support this modification and the continuation of our local aquaculture industry.
No attachments

Comment From: Cooke Aquaculture Pacific, LLC (Kevin Bright)

10/22/20 @ 4:00 PM
Attachments:

Comment From: Aquacare Environment Inc (Henning Gatz)

10/22/20 @ 7:48 AM
We support Cooke Aquaculture Pacific in their application to convert the sea cage sites to Steelhead grow-out. We know CAP to be a conscientious and environmentally sensitive operator with a very qualified and dedicated team of Washingtonians to ope...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Lyn Kerschen

10/22/20 @ 7:07 AM
No steelhead! Cooke has had their chance at responsible farming and blew it. Studies have increasingly shown that fish raised in open water pens can have significant negative impacts on wild salmon populations and the environment. The practice usual...↓

No attachments

Comment From: Harriet Holmgren

10/22/20 @ 5:28 AM
I think all permits should be provisional given Cook's history of not ensuring that the fish cannot escape. Even though these fish are native they are not the same as the wild fish (DNA may be the same but the environment/life experience is not - epi...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Corinne Asher

10/22/20 @ 4:07 AM
Cooke Aquaculture has already displayed their negligence and incompetence. Please do not give them or any other Net Pen company the opportunity to endanger native fish/marine populations and pollute the water. We must do everything to guard the saf...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Matthew Baerwalde

10/22/20 @ 3:19 AM
Comments of Snoqualmie Indian Tribe are attached. Thank you for the opportunity to comment.
Attachments:

Comment From: Kristin Balmet

10/22/20 @ 1:42 AM
Let's work to restore NATIVE species to their natural habitats. Perhaps muscle farming would be a safer and cleaner possibility for fish farming. Thank you for all your Time and hard work.

No attachments

Comment From: Chris Long

10/21/20 @ 4:15 PM
Net pens open to the ocean have been shown in recent research studies in BC to have negative impacts on wild salmon and steelhead. BC is removing their pens by 2025 based on this science. WA should not ignore it and jeopardize our few remaining wild ...↓

Also, from an economic perspective, net pens exploit our natural resources to benefit only a few people who own the company. Healthy fish populations are far more beneficial to the state's overall economy, since sport fishers spend hundreds of dollars a trip at local businesses. Don't risk killing the golden goose.
No attachments

Comment From: Annabella House Fox

10/21/20 @ 4:00 PM
Attachments:

Comment From: Support Mariculture

10/21/20 @ 8:46 AM
I am in support of the modifications Ecology has made to the draft NPDES permits for the Cooke Aquaculture operations. Cooke's transition to growing native species will be good for creating a sustainable seafood source that can be locally grown and w...↓

Ecology has put forward multiple safeguards and environmental reporting requirements that will help further minimize risk, potential impacts and maintain water quality conditions around these types of farm sites. Aquatic farms need clean, healthy water to grow healthy fish. This is true for aquatic farms just as much as it is true that land farms require the maintenance of healthy soil to raise healthy crops. To my knowledge, the fish farms have been growing fish in them for over 30 years in Puget Sound. If there was negative impacts to the surrounding water or sediments, it is doubtful they would be able to continue growing fish in these same locations. The different companies that have operated the farms over this time have all made their mistakes or had accidents happen. Fish farming is not an easy industry. It is fishing and farming combined. Both require you to work in and with Mother Nature and as anybody that fishes or farms already knows, she can be a harsh teacher at times. Like anything we humans do, we learn from our mistakes and try to do things better the next time. In my opinion, Cooke needs to be given a chance to try to do things better. Transitioning to sterile steelhead native trout is a step in the right direction.

- Seafood production will need to increase to provide more food for the expected increased human growth in the human population that is forecasted to occur in the next 30 years. The United Nation global demographic data shows an increase of 2 billion additional people will inhabit the planet by the year 2050. Most of this population growth is expected to occur in areas that are already poor in protein resources and/ or rely primarily on natural seafood resources that are being stretched to capacity already.

- Fishery experts agree that significant increases in the U.S. and global capture fisheries are generally unlikely to occur because most currently utilized capture fisheries have been at their maximum sustainable yield for the past 30 years or longer. Increasing, and most importantly, securing global food production resources will become even more important over the next several decades.

- Wild capture fisheries for most of the traditional northwest fish species are in decline or are currently at their maximum harvestable yields to sustain the species.

- Tribal and commercial fisheries in Washington, Oregon and California do not exist at anywhere near their historic levels. By working on the water and working with fish, aquaculture can provide locally produced seafood, employment opportunities, and help to maintain this region's cultural connection to producing food from the sea.

- There is scientific agreement that increasing mariculture (ocean farming) will have less environmental impact than a proportional increase in terrestrial food production systems. There is a finite amount of freshwater available for an increase in terrestrial agriculture and most suitable growing areas have fully exploited freshwater resources.

- Mariculture, done correctly and responsibly, can be a sustainable resource for seafood and become a resource to help supplement salmon enhancement, recovery operations and possibly even Orca recovery.

- WDNR and the other state agencies have refocused their regulations and helped to make the necessary corrections that will guide the marine net pen industry to more environmentally sound and sustainable practices. Strict regulations continue to make Washington's aquaculture operations part of the long term, sustainable solution to increasing seafood for human consumption.

- If we want to eat it, we better learn how to grow it.

No attachments

Comment From: Olympic Environmental Council (Darlene Schanfald)

10/21/20 @ 7:23 AM
The Olympic Environmental Council has long been concerned about raising fish in pens and has tracked this industry for over 20 years. To be brief, our position opposes raising penned animals, feeding them toxic feed which then circulates through the...↓

No attachments

Comment From: Craig Clark

10/21/20 @ 5:08 AM
I am in complete favor of going forward in allowing Cooke Aquaculture to farm steelhead in our local waters.
We need seafood, jobs, tax revenues, economic activity, and to food produce more of our food locally, rather than rely on importing it from ov...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Dan Swecker

10/20/20 @ 12:34 AM
As a retired state Senator and former fish farmer, I fully understand the risks and impacts of a commercial net pen operation the environment and native stocks. In addition to our freshwater operation in Rochester, WA,. my company also applied and re...↓

During my tenure in the Senate, I also served on the Natural Resources Committee for 18 years, and am very familiar not only with the status of stocks in Puget Sound, but also the various impacts on them as well as the potential for threats that might cause a deleterious effect on them.

While it has been shown beyond a doubt that Atlantics cannot and do not breed with native Pacific salmon stocks, the decision by Cooke Aquaculture to switch to sterile, all-female, triploid, Rainbow Trout/Steelhead is the very best option for eliminating any possible impact on the environment or native stocks. Should any of these fish escape, they will not reproduce because they are sterile. In fact the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife routinely stocks these same fish in freshwater lakes throughout the state.

The preference for these fish is that they grow faster than other fish (considered an advantage by sportsmen). In addition, they will not reproduce and compete with native stocks. The state uses the same process as the private sector to create triploid fish that they routinely introduce in bodies of water though out the state. There are no chemicals used to do this. Instead, at fertilization, the eggs are subjected to high pressure for a few minutes which causes them to retain three sets of chromosomes. This results in the eggs that produce only sterile fish.

With regard to disease, these stocks are certified disease-free prior to entry in saltwater. The only possible disease- transfer that might occur would be from wild fish to the commercial stocks in the net pens. If such a transfer should occur, the problem would be detected right away and appropriate action would be taken to resolve it. This would result in no additional risk to native stocks.

In my 18-year experience as a legislator, I saw no legitimate statewide policy or priority that these fish being used for commercial aquaculture would impact. Some public policies would be greatly enhanced. One of those is the need for jobs in our rural communities. In the recent past, commercial net pen aquaculture has provided up to 400 jobs at any one time. The economic viability of some of these communities is heavily dependent on commercial aquaculture.

It has been suggested that the areas occupied by the net pens would be better utilized for recreational access. It is important to remember that most of rural Puget Sound is available for this purpose. Very little of the land is set aside to use for aquaculture. Around the world other countries and making huge efforts to expand aquaculture. It is now producing most of the seafood that we consume. It is critical that our country participate and remain competitive in the international marketplace.

I would like to make a strong recommendation that this application be approved for the good of rural communities, our natural resources and the state as a whole. Let's stop importing these products from other countries and produce them ourselves.

Sincerely,
Dan Swecker
Senator, retired

No attachments

Comment From: Shaun Hubbard

10/19/20 @ 4:00 PM
Attachments:

Comment From: State Senator (Christine Rolfes)

10/19/20 @ 6:59 AM
Attachments:

Comment From: Martha Hall

10/19/20 @ 6:36 AM
I'm sorry that our legislature did not just ban in-water fish farms in Puget Sound in 2018. I'm sorry WDFW is issuing a permit to Cooke to raise native fish in Puget Sound at 4 sites, one near me, Hope Island. Many negative impacts have not changed b...↓

I listened to the oral comments from a person who said humans must have a source of fish. He also said now and in the future more of the fish will come from "fish farms" rather than from wild salmon. I disagree with both of his statements. Humans do not have to eat fish. That's a choice. There are many other sources of protein, and far safer sources that have not been pumped full of antibiotics as they are produced. If farmed fish are not available, all fish would come from wild sources and this would be far better for the Salish Sea. It would honor our pledge to lead in protecting the Salish Sea by banning fish farms. We can then hope Canada will do this too. As our human population grows and our the Salish Sea suffers from the impacts of climate change more and more, humans will need to make some hard choices, like change our eating habits so we eat far less meat and fish. As we see more of the negative impacts of our over-use of antibiotics when producing meat and fish we will need to take them out of food production. Factory farms are not safe for the animals that must live in them until they were killed and eaten, "harvested" and their products are not safe for humans and our pets.

The pollution caused by the fish food, fish feces and antibiotics coming from pens that use the waters of the Salish Sea is just plain unacceptable to many of us who have worked hard to reduce and stop pollution. We are working hard to try to protect our declining populations of salmon and resident orcas. It seems like our state agencies should be doing the same.

Allowing factory farms, fish farms, to operate in the waters of the Salish Sea is extraordinarily short-sighted. Everything inside of the nets on these fish farms may get out including diseases, feces, antibiotics, and fish food. These create point-source pollution and the Department of Ecology is going to issue permits for this! This is shocking after all of the efforts of the people of WA State to clean-up the Salish Sea. Our cities are spending millions on wastewater treatment. We are checking our outfalls. Boats must store sewage. Farmers are being told to fence off riparian areas to keep livestock feces out of streams that flow into the Salish Sea.We've spent millions trying to "save our salmon" through dozens of efforts. Why,
when our state agencies move ahead to give permits for fish farms that we do not need to have in WA State. The fish farms generate a few jobs, very few.
Profits go to Cooke, not the people of WA State. We just get the pollution!

As to the so-called stricter pollution standards, I find the self-reporting by Cooke on various items like the monthly reports on fish food consumption and monitoring for escaped farmed fish totally unacceptable. Cooke clearly demonstrated that a third-party is needed to oversee all of its operation on at least a weekly basis if not daily. Cooke has a long history of not reporting and properly dealing with diseases in fish in its pens. It tried to avoid responsibility for the collapse of the net pen near my home and lied to us saying it was caused by unusual circumstances. Escapes have not been reported. Why does the Dept. of Ecology think Cooke will operate any differently in the future? Who believes Cooke will closely monitor and report escaped fish or food consumption or use of antibiotics or anything else?

Sustainable agriculture, in the water and on land, should be our goal. Factory farming in the Salish Sea or the Skagit Valley farmland is not sustainable. It is also not humane to the poor animals, the fish, who live their lives crammed into over-crowded pens and fed antibiotics to keep them artificially healthy. This should not be part of our vision for the future in the State of WA. We don't have to have fish farms in our state. We'll be able to get enough protein without fish farms. I'm very disappointed in our legislature for not banning all fish farms and I'm disappointed in my three state agencies who have lined up to issue permits to Cooke for factory farming in the Salish Sea.
No attachments

Comment From: Kent Hoium

10/19/20 @ 3:35 AM
Raising Steelhead in Puget Sound will provide local seafood without harvesting the wild fish stocks which other wildlife depends on. It will also provide employment and tax revenue to the local economy. The only difference in the environmental impact...↓
I support the approval of the Permits allowing Steelhead to be raised here in Washington.

No attachments

Comment From: Isa Werny

10/18/20 @ 5:04 AM
It is time we stop all fish farms. Cook does not have a good record. They are not even a Washington company.
No attachments

Comment From: Jayni Detrick

10/16/20 @ 1:45 AM
As the closest neighbor to Cooke Aguaculture Pacific, the latest owner of the fish farming operation on Rich Passage, Bainbridge Island, we have witnessed their(and past owners)farming of Atlantic salmon in an artificial environment for 25 years. Al...↓
Although I am a free market, pro business and farming, citizen, fish farming businesses don't belong in our Puget Sound waters.
Thank you.
No attachments

Comment From: Laurie Sander

10/15/20 @ 6:40 AM
Fish farms do not contribute to the health and well being of Puget Sound and its wildlife. With all the stresses already on our oceans from increased population, acidification and other climate-related changes, the last thing we need is a fish farm ...↓

Cooke Aquaculture has a documented history of lying: they lied about the number of fish that escaped in 2017, they didn't report diseases in the escaped fish, and it is in their interest to continue lying about the health of any fish in the future. We can't afford to give them another chance to injure Washington's waters and wildlife.

Whether the farmed fish are fertile or infertile, Atlantic or native, the risk of any adverse effects on wild fish and the environment is too high.

Thank you for considering this layperson's opinion.
No attachments

Comment From: Andrew Wynne

10/15/20 @ 2:00 AM
To whom it may concern:

We tend to hear about loopholes when they involve money (loopholes in tax codes, energy permits, and land).

Now fish

Steelhead vs Salmon. This loophole is the only reason we are still having this conversation. This is not what ...↓

Jobs will be created with the proposed land use from Wild Fish Conservancy plan which will support the cleanup and resulting dock use.

The current jobs at the facility are skilled workers (welders, divers) who have the skills to find employment at other facilities. This is not about losing work.

This is about stopping a foreign corporation from exposing a loophole.

Stop this permit, and stop this loophole.
No attachments

Comment From: Doug Simms

10/14/20 @ 5:59 AM
I fully support Cooke Aquaculture Pacific's move to produce triploid steelhead at all their marine sites.
As we have endured covid 19 over the past several months, the importance for locally produced foods from both land and sea has become more appare...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Lauralee Carbone

10/14/20 @ 5:31 AM
Friends don't let friend buy/eat farmed fish. Polluting. Can effect wild fish. Just say no and do the right thing.
No attachments

Comment From: Hugh Mitchell

10/13/20 @ 4:00 PM
All right. Okay, well, thanks for this opportunity. So, I am-- I have two degrees in marine biology and marine ecology, bachelor's and master's. I have a doctorate in veterinary medicine, and I've been practicing fish medicine for over 30 years all o...↓

 

Currently, the US is an embarrassment to the rest of the world. I mean, by that, we import $20 billion dollars more seafood than we produce. Half of the deficit is made up with imported foreign sea food. We lag woefully behind in volume technology and know-how with most of our seafood produced internationally outside our control and economic benefit. The gap is widening because we are bogged down in silly, vested politics that hamper current aquaculture production and constrain any real growth. Real science is ignored and fear mongering politics and frivolous lawsuits abound.

 

Now, environmentally, Norway with its pristine, pure fjords, which are a priceless tourist attraction still has close to a 1,000 net pens. The sights growing 2 million metric tons of salmon in these fields and along its coastline. Salmon is its number two export, and the only significant discharge the oceans from this vast number of farms is nitrogen, and, as, you know, nitrogen is an essential nutrient for primary production at the very base of the food web of the ocean ecosystem.

 

There are countless other sources, but it's not it's a necessary nutrient for all life in our sees. The key is not to overload the input as excess can result in harmful algal blooms and anoxic conditions

 

Study after study in Norway and Puget Sound has shown that the nitrogen output from salmon grown and net-pens is insignificant compared to all other sources and to the overall and nitrogen budget. In fact, the original 1990 EIS study by Washington Department of Fisheries, which has been criticized for being dated, calculated the Puget Sound could sustain a 100 net-pen sites without significant impact.

 

Even if conditions of change in the relevance of this study is in question, we're only talking about four sites here, not a 100, and for 40 years before Cooke rescued the business, and I've done contract work for Cooke and for previous owners, these sites have operated without a single shred of evidence that their nitrogen output is of any concern. In fact, several studies have shown that it isn't, and as we all are aware a couple years ago, the state made non-native fish, such as Atlantic salmon, illegal for net pen aquaculture, even though the scientific evidence is scant, but Cooke complied and is planning to switch to native and sterile rainbow trout/steelhead, so it doesn't lose the time honored important, maritime business, and its workforce of very skilled and underappreciated animal husbandry technicians remain.

 

So Department of Ecology's net-pens permit for Cooke needs to be changed from Atlantic salmon to a sterile rainbow trout and the production here, we're only talking about 8,000 metric tons, if that. This should not have taken a hearing or a comment period, such as this to do so, but that's part of politics of aquaculture in the Pacific Northwest these days.

 

Scientifically, there is no difference between the nitrogen output of two salmonids Atlantic salmon and steelhead. Furthermore, as several escapee [phonetic] over the years before Cooke, there's been no impact whatsoever of these fish on established runs, but with current technology escapee [phonetic] risk is far less and sterile steel had would even less than that risk disease.

 

Risk is not an issue. That's my field. I'm not going to elaborate in that for the sake of time, but I'll just stand and say the Department of Ecology, if acting scientifically, has no choice but to immediately implement the permit modification.

Thank you
No attachments

Comment From: Kevin Bright

10/13/20 @ 4:00 PM
Hi, I'm Kevin Bright. I work at Cooke Aquaculture now. I started in this business in 1990. I've got a degree in marine biology, and I truly believe that aquaculture is the answer to providing food for people, just like agriculture on land provides fo...↓

 

So, I just wanted to say that in 1996 the first and NPDES permits for commercial net pen operations were issued. Those permits required the company to report monthly feed, monthly antibiotic use and monthly biomass for the site, so since 1996, the various companies have been required by the NPDES permit to report all those quantities in ecology, so they have that data. It's publicly available to people, and it's been publicly available since 1996.

 

I think, in my opinion, ecology has these additional permit modifications and additions that ecology has developed more than adequately will further safeguard the water quality conditions around these facilities. This is a switch from one species of salmonid to another species of salmonid. The fish feeds that we will use are going to be nearly identical and as pointed out in the application materials, probably shorter growing periods, which means increased fallowing periods and more resting periods between generations of fish.

 

When I first started, we had three generations of the fish at the site. Those sites never went empty. We were adding juvenile fish onto adult fish and the pens constantly remain full of fish. Now we've got a break in the cycle. You put a generation in and then you pull them out. That's a standard aquaculture practice for various reasons. It gives a resting period to the environment. It breaks any disease cycles if there are any. Any parasite cycles if there are any.

 

It's no different than what happens when you drive through the fields out there in the Skagit Valley and there's nothing planted. There's no tulips. It's an empty field, right? So we take a rest and break, give nature a chance to take a breather.

 

Ecology's never been easy with the since these NPDES permits came about. Every year that they-- every permit cycle that they've been renewed, there's been new and additional requirements of the industry- pollution prevention plans, escape prevention plans, more reporting. These permits now we are going to do more water quality, sampling, more benthic sediment sampling annually, and sometimes twice a year no for benthic sampling.

 

So, ecology's done a job of increasing the regulatory environment around aquaculture in Washington State and it's done a good job, I believe, in helping this industry evolve. It's a new industry and it's an evolved and it's adapted and I think this is a step of the right direction to start raising sterile, native, all female triploid steelhead, and we're not raising a non-native species anymore. We're raising a native species, which is what a lot of people wanted us to do a long time ago. I had lots of my friends ask me why we weren't raising native species and I gave them various explanations why Atlantic salmon was the fish of choice at the time in the 1990's, but the world's changed and this is a native species and there's a market for steelhead. There's a market for fresh, sustainable seafood and there's a market for jobs in this environment, so that's what I want to say, and thank you for your time. 
No attachments

Comment From: Kurt Grinnell

10/13/20 @ 4:00 PM
Okay, good evening and thank you again. Kurt Grinnell from the Jamestown S'Klallam tribe again. I'm a councilman and a natural resource policy rep. I'm also head of our seafood aquaculture programs and on behalf of the tribe, I'd like to say, hello t...↓

 

So, the Jamestown tribe's a sovereign nation, but we're really not truly sovereign unless we can feed our people and with the state of affairs, with our wild salmon, as much as we've worked on the habitat, all the issues out there surrounding the survival rates of our needed populations and fish out there, generally our seafood, Jamestown has decided to begin an aquaculture program They actually tried to start in the 80's, were unable to do so with then fish production.

 

Well, we do have two hatcheries. We do have two shellfish hatcheries currently raising geoduck and oysters and we also have a pretty large nursery system here in Sequim Bay.

 

We also are in a partnership with NOAA and the University of Washington growing all female, native sablefish. We hope to bring these two viable commercial interest in the future, which also looks good and again we talked about native species -  when the Atlantic’s were on their way out we had decided and I testified whether tribal leaders that we would be okay with the native species to farm these fish, and we were already in the businesses. Other tribes in the business as tribes with over two million coho and net-pens and they release them and they come back and they catch them and so the sport fissures and other people in the community, and we don't have a big problem with that. We haven't had three fish that are released, and without these hatchery fish, these net-pen fish that are  released, we really wouldn't have any fish with catch.

 

But really, our sovereignty is in our tribe is food sovereignty. If we are unable to feed ourselves and history shows that with tribes there have been periods of times that we have not been able to feed our own people, and we're just start to fail as a culture and as a society, and so we are very, very supportive of the decision by Ecology to, you know, to okay these permits. Same with WDFW. We believe in their science. We're very science based in Jamestown. That's all we have. We do believe in science. It's what we do, and we feel that that done properly using best practices, best science, that aquaculture, whether it's shellfish or fish, they should be done sustainably, and we look seven generations down the road.

 

A lot of people know that's how we, the Indian tribes, look. We look at our futures. We look out seven generations. We want to know that we are going to be able to feed our people and create jobs and teach our people how to grow their own food into the future when we're here and when we are all long gone.

 

We, and also we do, we realize there's been a release of fish and shortly after Cooke purchased the operations from Icicle, had Icicle held on to the operations for another six or eight months, it would have collapsed on them, so we realize in every kind of industry, there's accidents, there's mistakes that happen or in this case, maybe pens were in disrepair, and so we realize that after spending a lot of time with Cooke, looking at all their operations throughout Canada and down here in Washington state, we think that there that their heads up in their operations and they're good folks.

 

We have partnered with Cooke and we hope to begin operations to raise these sterile, native steelhead and our sablefish and, you know, in possibly Port Angeles Harbor.

 

So I just want to reiterate our support for these decisions to allow us, not just Cooke, but other tribes that like us-- there are other tribes in Washington state, I know, that are that are raising steelhead trout to adulthood to maybe 2 million pounds in a month, so this is not new to Washington state. Steelhead are being raised already. There are other tribes out to the raising [inaudible] and releasing them, so I think this is kind of semantics in some way. There's a lot of fish rearing going on between net-pens and hatcheries, and then they're splitting hairs on how long to raise them and whether you release them or do you just harvest them right out of the net.

And so, yeah, so anyway, this does give Jamestown somewhat of a guarantee into the future for food, sovereignty, food security jobs for our people and also helps our tax base, so I thank you. Appreciate your time. 
 
No attachments

Comment From: Jim Parsons

10/13/20 @ 4:00 PM
Thank you. So, my name is Jim Parsons. I'm the general manager for Cooke Aquacultures Pacific Operations here in Washington State. We truly appreciate the Department of Ecology for their thorough review of the existing science that was used in determ...↓

 

We will reserve our comments on specific aspects of the permit changes involving increase data submission and analysis of our operational factors for our written this month.

 

It does seem appropriate at this time, however, to remind our regulatory agencies and those listening that the United States currently imports 80% to 90% of its seafood. Given that food has been shown to be increasingly important for our collective health and that over half of the seafood that is imported comes from aquaculture operations in foreign lands, which may be far less regulated than that in our own country and state

 

Food and nutritional security alone should dictate that we should be looking at ways to increase [audio breaking up] instead of reducing or eliminating it. Couple of the importance of rural, working waterfront economies and employment, we clearly need to expand this industry.

 

All food production systems have some form of environmental impact. Latest research trends from throughout the globe are finally demonstrating that the growing of aquatic organisms is one of the most environmentally friendly forms of protein production on our planet. CAP will continue to work with regulators to implement new production technologies as they develop and to continuously improve our operations and minimize our impact, while providing much needed local and safe seafood to our communities.

 

Thank you for the time to comment tonight. 
No attachments

Comment From: Jeanne McKnight

10/13/20 @ 4:00 PM
Alright, thank you. Yes, I'm Jeannie McKnight, and I'm the executive director of the Northwest Aquaculture Alliance, formerly the Washington Fish birds Association. We changed our name to reflect the fact that our members represent growers such as Co...↓

 

I want to thank you for the opportunity to talk tonight. We are absolutely convinced as an alliance, and we are one of many such organizations throughout the world that aquaculture, whether it's marine, freshwater or closed containment has a role to play as others have mentioned in food security and the creation of robust blue economy here in Washington.

 

Others have talked about the fact that we import 90% of the seafood or 80 to 90%, so I don't need to go into that too much, but one thing I must say is that one of the lessons that we've learned from the pandemic is that we need to grow our own and we need to become better at growing our own seafood, because we are just one pandemic away from borders being closed and food not being able to come our way.

 

I want to also say that prior to becoming the agriculture alliance, the fish growers association conducted some consumer research, and one of the things that came up in that research of 700 Washington households, western Washington households was that overwhelmingly, and I can provide backup for this - this was done by GMA research - overwhelmingly people felt that aquaculture done sustainably, fish farming done sustainably was something that they could accept, and part of that came from people feeling that they wanted - this pre-pandemic - that they wanted to have locally grown food.

 

Tonight we're here to support our member Cooke Aquaculture Pacific and its request to grow sterile rainbow trout in the four net-pen sites that were previously permitted for Atlantic salmon. We're here not just for Cooke, though. We're here I'm here, to talk about the fact that it is whole idea of opening up our economy to aquaculture as the rest of the country, the rest of the world has done is something that is so important right now.

 

As an aside we now know that there was a growing body of evidences in the record, in the public record, about steelhead being nearly identical to that in the use of in feed conversion to Atlantic salmon. In fact, after Ron Hardy, a leading researcher on this topic, believes that steelhead made metabolize commercial fish feeds more efficiently than Atlantic salmon do and meaning that the proposed switch maybe in fact more beneficial to water quality.

 

I want to also say that I've worked aquaculture business for the past 25 years. I started out my career working for the Alaska Seafood Marketing Institute at an organization called the West Coast Fisheries Development Foundation. Absolutely loved working for the wild fish sector, but as luck would have it, salmon runs were depleting, commercial, let's say whether you were trolling or trying to get bottom fish, you know, things have changed in the environment and even though the US has a very well managed fishery, climate is changing and fish are going elsewhere, so we can't we can't catch enough fish to feed our people, so we've got to do something about this.

 

Not only does marine aquaculture, however, have the lowest environmental footprint of any animal protein farming production system on the planet, but it has lower feed requirements, lowest water usage, low energy requirements, resulting in low greenhouse gas emissions, and everybody's in love with these days. They think that and some previous speakers have alluded to this about closed containment land-based systems. We, the alliance believe that we need all forms of aquaculture, and we are here to support because we believe that this will become the basis of a very robust economy here.

 

On a final note, I often get messages from colleagues and friends that I've met through my work in aquaculture all around the world saying what is going on in Washington state. What they mean is, why all the hurdles? Why the opposition? And why can't Washington get with the program? And believe me what happens in Washington does not stay here when it comes to aquaculture. People are watching all over. The eyes of the world are upon us, but with these permit modifications, and the requirements that, go with it, we think we have the chance to do things, right. To lead the nation and becoming a sustainable producer of nutritious seafood. The production of which will create much needed employment opportunities here in Washington.

 

I personally and we trust that the Department of Ecology will make the right final decision in the right way to permit modification based on science and not politics. Thank you.

 
No attachments

Comment From: Walt Dickhoff

10/13/20 @ 4:00 PM
All right, thank you. I'm Walt Dickhoff, retired professor of fisheries, University of Washington, retired senior scientist with NOAA Fisheries. I've been-- I worked with salmon net-pens for 40 years in Puget Sound, and have quite a big experience.

&n...↓

I'd like just to comment that we've looked at impacts of salmon net-pen rearing in Puget Sound on endangered species, including Pacific salmon in southern resident killer whales and we never considered them a major threat to those groups. There are persistent organic pollutants that are a major threat to whose southern resident killer whales, but these are mostly of terrestrial origin and not really a threat from net-pen culture. So, I like to commend the Department of Ecology for developing these guidelines and working with Cooke and urge their approval of the permit. So, thank you for this opportunity. 
No attachments

Comment From: Shari Tarantino

10/13/20 @ 4:00 PM
My name Shari Tarantino. I am the executive director for the Seattle based nonprofit, Orca Conservancy, and we work on recovering and advocating for the critically endangered population of southern resident, killer whales.

 

We focus on law and sc...↓

 

Congress responding to the nation's need for clean water supplies tasks the Clean Water Act to creating means by which to reduce the amount of water pollution nationwide. In order to correct the water pollution program the Clean Water Act defines the term "discharge of pollutants" to mean, any addition of any pollutant to navigable waters from any point source.

 

The Clean Water Act defines a point source as any discernible, confined and discreet conveyance, including, but not limited to any pipe, ditch, channel, tunnel, conduit, well, discrete fissure, container, rally, stock, concentrated animal feeding operation or vessel, or other flooding craft from which pollutants are, or may be discharged.

 

Nonpoint sources are defined as those sources not traceable to a single conveyance. Additionally, the Clean Water Act defines "pollutant" as a direct spoil, solid waste, incinerator, residue, sewage garbage, sewage sludge, munitions chemical waste, biological materials, radioactive materials, heat, racked or discarded equipment, rocks and cellar dirt, industrial municipal and agricultural waste discharged into the water.

 

This Clean Water Act extends to both animate and inanimate pollutants. The statute, for example, regulates fecal coliform, living bacteria as conventional pollutants in the Washington Pollution Control Board has also found that escaped salmon are agricultural or industrial waste.

 

Another statutory example of the definition of a pollutant.

As a federal government also considers aquaculture to be a form of agriculture, escaped salmon may similarly be treated as agricultural industrial waste under the Clean Water Act. Our goal, obviously, is to work towards advocating for the critically endangered population of southern resident killer whales.

 

Open net farms, regardless of the species, can discharge significant amounts of waste water, containing nutrients, chemicals and pharmaceuticals that impact the surrounding environment. I mean, I can go on and on. Furthermore, feed and fecal matter from these facilities can deplete the dissolved oxygen concentrations around and certainly within the facilities. Even the anti-following agents, copper, which I need to research, to keep these cages and pens clean are highly toxic.

 

Therefore, Orca Conservancy and its 45,000+ members and supporters stand in direct opposition of said permits from Cooke Aquaculture. This company is not a good respectable neighbor. They have proven time and time again that they are unable to be respectful to our waterways.

 

We have welcomed them into our waters and they have done nothing but disrupt and decimate what our waters are trying to protect.

Please rescind this permit if at all possible and protect our waterways, our salmon, and our critically endangered population of southern resident killer whales. Thank you. 
No attachments

Comment From: Caroline Armon

10/13/20 @ 7:18 AM
Please do not permit Cooke Aquaculture Pacific to raise steelhead or any fish in Washington State waters,
based on their previous neglect, deception, WDFW statement
"After scientific review, WDFW determined that raising steelhead trout in the existing ...↓

Washington State Department of Ecology are caretakers of our public waters and lands, our representatives, and the majority of we public do not support our waters being used and decimated for corporate profit.

I support, WSDE please also support
Wild Fish Conservancy seeking to restore the sites to their natural states and to restore full access for public use. As Executive Director Kurt Beardslee said "Leasing these lands for the purpose of restoring Puget Sound is consistent with the will of the public and will provide broad cultural, social, and economic benefits for all citizens while restoring direct access to 130 acres of public waters for the first time in over thirty years.
Buying the rights to the sites and removing the pens would, cost-to-benefit-wise, be one of the best restoration projects in 30 years."

Sincerely,
Caroline Armon
Marine Ecology Educator
Field Research
No attachments

Comment From: Martine Springer

10/13/20 @ 12:46 AM
The aquaculture industry in Washington state has proven to be a total failure from the perspective of ecosystem management and conservation of native species. The latest proposal to use "native" steelhead means that genetically-modified "domesticated...↓

While the threat of domesticated strains of native fish escaping and damaging endangered runs of steelhead is a new threat, the old problems of high fecal bacteria pollution and low-oxygen benthic zones remains. Worse still, aquaculture fish pens are proven reservoirs of deadly disease and parasites that quickly jump to wild fry, smolt, and adults that pass too close to the pens.

Apart from the glaring biological problems, players such as Cooke Aquaculture have proven to be bad faith actors. They have a long history of failing to perform basic maintenance and preventing escapage. They should be prohibited from participating in any aquaculture activities in Washington state.

No attachments

Comment From: John Forster

10/12/20 @ 6:04 AM
I have worked in the the aquaculture industry and related research activities since 1965, including 31 years in Washington State where participated in several different aquaculture activities, including management of the salmon farm in Port Angeles H...↓

I believe Cooke Aquaculture's plan to switch production to sterile Steelhead Trout in its Washington farms makes good sense. If approved it will keep alive an industry in Washington that started in the 1970's and has grown worldwide so that fresh farmed salmon and trout are now readily available year round to most U.S. consumers. During this time the industry worldwide has innovated and made great improvements in its practices and the design and operation of the equipment used.

Cooke Aquaculture is a global leader in the salmonid farming industry and Washington State is fortunate to have such a company willing to invest in and develop the salmonid farming industry there. In the years ahead there is no doubt that the salmonid farming industry will continue to innovate and grow and with Cooke Aquaculture as it's leading producer the State is in a good position to benefit from this growth.
No attachments

Comment From: John Denlter

10/09/20 @ 12:16 PM
Attachments:

Comment From: Duane Edwards

10/09/20 @ 3:53 AM
I am against all farm raised fish but especially Atlantic salmon
No attachments

Comment From: Jamie Kitson

10/09/20 @ 2:34 AM
I believe there should be no permits issued for net pen fish farms in the Puget sound or any of the interconnected waterways. The threat of disease and interference with migration of endangered Pacific salmon and steelhead is too great. These populat...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Janet Marx

10/07/20 @ 11:13 AM
Has Ecology ever conducted a survey of the sea floor (benthic layer, micro sea life, forage fish populations, etc.) prior to installation of a net pen operation and then conducted a follow-up survey four or five years later to determine changes to th...↓

If not, how can you approve an open net pen permit?
No attachments

Comment From: Cathleen Burns

10/01/20 @ 12:03 PM
Please deny permits for more Cooke aquaculture! We already know the disasterous results of their last attempt to make $ at the expense of our environment. No matter the supposed safeguards required, more disasters are bound to occur. This is a det...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Sarah Kuh

9/29/20 @ 3:19 AM
Aquaculture provides a safe and sustainable food source as well as many living wage jobs. This change is minimal, and I believe Cooke should be able to move forward.
No attachments

Comment From: Polly Derr

9/28/20 @ 11:02 AM
Farmed fish lack the nutritional value and flavor of naturally grown fish in the wild. They also have a much higher fat content than normal. It is certainly not advisable to put farm pens anywhere there is an even remote chance that the farmed fish o...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Katherine Kirchhofer

9/28/20 @ 6:17 AM
Under no circumstance should we be opening another fish farm in Washington state. Beyond the violation of treaty right as stated in the Boldt decision, this can cause increased disease rates, decrease genetic diversity for fish best suited for the n...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Zoetic Research (Mark Lewis)

9/28/20 @ 5:33 AM
The aquaculture industry in Washington state has proven to be a total failure from the perspective of ecosystem management and conservation of native species. The latest proposal to use "native" steelhead means that genetically-modified "domesticated...↓

While the threat of domesticated strains of native fish escaping and damaging endangered runs of steelhead is a new threat, the old problems of high fecal bacteria pollution and low-oxygen benthic zones remains. Worse still, aquaculture fish pens are proven reservoirs of deadly disease and parasites that quickly jump to wild fry, smolt, and adults that pass too close to the pens.

Apart from the glaring biological problems, players such as Cooke Aquaculture have proven to be bad faith actors. They have a long history of failing to perform basic maintenance and preventing escapage. They should be prohibited from participating in any aquaculture activities in Washington state.
No attachments

Comment From: Cornelis Bakker

9/26/20 @ 10:23 AM
I applaud the aquaculture company rearing native steelhead instead of Atlantic salmon. I consider this a good use of the 4 areas and an appropriate response to the net pen collapse.
No attachments

Comment From: Lynda Cole

9/25/20 @ 12:45 PM
Why would the DOE and WDFW set themselves up for a class action suit by issuing a permit for pen raised fish? Why would you sell out the State by allowing the desecration of Puget Sound? Why are you selling out the salmon fishery of Washington stat...↓
There are many ways to enhance not only water quality, quality of life and salmon production. Look to Alaska's fish production and how much revenue it produces. The West Coast of the USA has the potential to feed a lot of the world. Why should we ever have to import fish?
Please be honest about the destruction of Puget Sound, it's natural stock, and water quality. What would issuing this permit make better? The revenue received is tantamount to prostitution. Who will pay for the clean-up??? the tax payers of Washington State. Who will pay when it's all gone? Most criminals get thrown in jail.
No attachments

Comment From: Peggy Most

9/24/20 @ 8:31 AM
Cooke has a terrible track record leading me to assume they care little for the environment of Puget Sound. How will they address the sea lice which are prevalent on pen fish? Those lice move freely from the pens to wild species.
Keep net pens out of ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Philip Forve

9/24/20 @ 7:31 AM
I am a private citizen who wants to go on record opposing these fish pens and any extension of the leases currently in force. We need to protect our natural environment and not destroy it with industrial fish farming methods. We are blessed in the ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Brett Wedeking

9/24/20 @ 2:03 AM
Do not issue new permits of modify existing permits for any fish farming in WA marine waters. Raising sterile rainbow trout is not any better than Atlantic salmon. They present the same problems with waste and pollution and sea lice that negatively a...↓

I am a fishing guide on Puget Sound and I see first hand the lack of fish that live near the Orchard Rocks pens. Bluntly, the fishing always sucks near those pens.

Rainbow trout present the same escape risks, and possibly worse, than Atlantic Salmon. Escapes are unavoidable and when fish escape they compete for food and space with wild species, again some of which are ESA listed. These pens must be in violation of both the ESA and Clean Water Act.

There is no guarantee that all these fish will be sterile. When those fish escape they can migrate up local rivers and interbreed with ESA listed, wild steelhead and dilute genetic diversity, contributing to further declines in survivability of wild steelhead.

The net pens are not worth it. The science is clear, it all points to net pens as bad for wild species and bad for people. WA is the last state or province on the West Coast to allow marine fish farming. All marine net pens need to be banned in this state as soon as possible.
No attachments

Comment From: BRIAN COWAN

9/22/20 @ 10:52 AM
Hi
I am writing to express my opposition to net pens operating in Washington State. The irresponsible management of the pens by Cooke should not be rewarded with more opportunities to adversely impact our ecosystem. There is too much at sake for our w...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Ruth LeBrun

9/22/20 @ 3:33 AM
I STRONGLY DO NOT SUPPORT any further operations by Cooke Aquaculture in Washington State waters. No further permits, no further changes in their operations, nothing. They have proven quite clearly that they are unable to manage net pens or have any ...↓
Our waters are fragile. Our native fish are decreasing constantly. The Orca whales are gravely endangered. How much longer are we going to despoil our land and water for private gain?
Think about PUBLIC gain! We need waters that are unspoiled, for all citizens to enjoy and appreciate. We are talking about the public trust here, land and seas.
No further Aquaculture - Cooke or other companies.
Thank you for your consideration.
Ruth LeBrun, Anacortes WA
No attachments

Comment From: Carol Truex

9/21/20 @ 4:00 PM
Attachments:

Comment From: Allan Holmes

9/21/20 @ 9:20 AM
The problem here is that for at least the last 30 YEARS we've been living here Cooke Aquaculture has promised and promised, but seldom, if ever, performed. It's time to end the charade. They've never been good neighbors for the 33 years we've lived ...↓

No attachments

Comment From: Cynthia Livingston

9/20/20 @ 2:28 PM
Cooke Aquaculture should be denied any permits to operate fish farms. Their negligence that led to the net breach and release of Atlantic salmon will likely be causing harm to our ecosystem for decades to come, in ways we may never understand. They h...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Nick Falls

9/20/20 @ 1:11 AM
To whom it may concern. This company should never be permitted to raise farmed non-native fish in the first place. Now they swing money in front of politicians and officials to keep they're profits up and pockets stuffed. They care not of our fragile...↓
No attachments

Comment From: John Corso

9/18/20 @ 3:18 AM
Generally, I support aquaculture as a means of reducing the harvest of wild fish and especially endangered and threatened species. However, I am concerned about the threat of disease and parasites in farmed stock infecting wild fish especially threa...↓
Thank you for considering my concerns and suggestions.
John Corso
No attachments

Comment From: Coastal Watershed Institute (Anne Shaffer)

9/18/20 @ 2:05 AM
Attached. Thank you for timely action to end inwater netpens in Washington state.jas
Attachments:

Comment From: Cindi Mcnabb

9/18/20 @ 12:06 AM
This is a horrific idea. Cooke aquaculture has proven they do not maintain their nets. The tragedy that befell our native fish at their hands is shameful. The oceans do not belong to them and NO PERMIT SHOULD BE GIVEN to them for steelhead
No attachments

Comment From: Owen Fairbank

9/17/20 @ 11:15 PM
The track record of Cooke Aquaculture and other firms shows that disease from the concentrations of fish spreads to wild populations, and also that no net pens can reliably contain fish 100% of the time. These unavoidable consequences mean that salt...↓
The responsible solution is to require all net pens to be situated on land with comprehensive treatment of the circulating water before it is returned to the ocean.
Is not the role of the Department of Ecology to protect the environment and ecology of the natural world? Is that not more important to us and future generations than short-term corporate profit for a few individuals?
Thank you for your consideration of the people and wildlife of Washington and the world.
No attachments

Comment From: Jacob Manning

9/17/20 @ 6:13 PM
Please do not allow these people to keep polluting our waters. Cooke is in the business of disease introduction. Raising Steelhead is worse than Atlantic Salmon as our native Steelhead are on a path to extinction.
No attachments

Comment From: Kristine Holm

9/17/20 @ 4:43 AM
Will the permit explain how the level of PCBs in the fish feed will be assessed and reduced as required by state regulations concerning PCBs in products? How will PCB assessment and treatment in feed be addressed as part of the AKART requirement? I d...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Jeremy Maldonado

9/17/20 @ 4:09 AM
This should not be allowed.
No attachments

Comment From: Duffy MCKENZIE

9/17/20 @ 2:14 AM
NO! NO! NO! Your industry has already proven itself incapable of securely containing your disease ridden faux food. Your industry is single handedly the greatest detriment to our wild salmon populations. Your permits should be revoked outright! The A...↓

Anyone who is interested, please watch the documentary Salmon Confidential. It is free on YouTube.
https://youtu.be/fTCQ2IA_Zss
No attachments

Comment From: Larry Jones

9/16/20 @ 12:10 PM
The oceans can no longer support the fishing needed to provide Food for the amount of people in this world. Aquaculture is the future whether people like it or not. The last thing this state should be doing is getting rid of more jobs
Attachments:

Comment From: STEVE KNUTZEN

9/16/20 @ 6:36 AM
When Cooke lost all those salmon, due to lack of maintenance and incompetence, they lied to the state and public on a daily basis for months. They have no right to be in business in our state, as they will no doubt continue to lie , break the rules, ...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Patrick Baumann

9/16/20 @ 12:47 AM
Cooke Aquaculture Pacific has proven again and again that they are poor stewards of the Salish Sea. In the past, when breaches have occurred, their only response was a litany if excuses. Before any new permit is granted, please verify new processes a...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Annie McIntyre

9/15/20 @ 2:08 PM
Please do not allow Cooke Aquaculture Pacific to lease any further areas in the Salish Sea. Cooke Aquaculture Pacific has proven themselves to be horrible stewards of their own fish pens and the environment surrounding those pens in the leases that t...↓
No attachments

Comment From: Anonymous Anonymous

9/15/20 @ 12:28 PM
I feel that there would be no difference in the environmental impact if Cooke was allowed to farm steelhead. Cooke should be allowed to move forward.
No attachments

[ Previous Page / Next Page ]